Try, learn and adjust
Check that diagnosis identifies operational gaps
- Plan: Ravi, a plant owner, receives one month of light diagnostic consulting, totalling about 30 hours.
- Try: Consultants observe inventory, maintenance and quality records, then compare practices with management benchmarks.
- Learn: Read the diagnostic report: which operational deficiencies are identified?
- Adjust: Keep the report’s identified gaps for review; clarify missing observations before treating diagnosis as complete.
Illustrative: Ravi is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested loop, not a tested source procedure. Observe benchmark scores and the report. Diagnosis does not include the intensive implementation support.
How
When to use
Manufacturing plants in developing countries often operate without knowing where their operational weaknesses lie. Plant owners lack clear baseline data on how their practices compare to global standards. This method uses short-term diagnostic audits to measure plant practices without delivering full implementation support.
Conduct a one-month diagnostic consulting evaluation across plant operations.
- Assign external consultants to spend 30 hours analyzing factory floor processes.
- Consultants observe existing inventory tracking, machinery maintenance, and quality recording.
- Consultants score the plant against standardized international management benchmarks.
- Consultants present an evaluation report highlighting operational deficiencies to plant owners.
Why it works
They reveal plant weaknesses to owners without committing resources to long-term implementation support.
Example
Control plants in large Indian textile manufacturing firms received one month of light diagnostic consulting totaling about 30 hours. Consultants measured baseline practices and identified major operational deficiencies across plants.
About the study
Participants
Large Indian textile manufacturing plants with a median asset value of 13.3 million dollars.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial where control plants received one month of light diagnostic consulting to isolate the effect of intensive five-month consulting given to treatment plants.
Results
Control plants receiving one month of light consulting showed minimal operational improvement compared to treatment plants that received five months of hands-on implementation guidance.