Original source
Why Do Firms in Developing Countries Have Low Productivity? (2010)
Research synthesis article · American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings · 100(2), 619–623
Read the source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Establish structured financial delegation thresholds permitting middle managers to approve routine operational expenditures independently.
Delegate predefined purchasing authorization limits to plant managers for routine maintenance and operational supplies to eliminate downtime caused by approval delays.
"In the BEMMR textile firms, every purchase order typically required the sign-off from the owner, even orders for a $25 spare part."
Establish credit assessment frameworks based on verified managerial competency and business plans rather than physical asset collateral alone.
"Second, even if financing is not such a constraint for existing (large) firms, financing obstacles are likely to limit the extent to which individuals with better managerial talent, but low capital, can start and grow enterprises to compete with badly managed firms."
Deploy digital inventory and production logging systems to establish transparent operational auditing before granting managerial autonomy.
"Since firms in developing countries do not have good data systems for measuring outputs, inputs, inventories, and spares, the opportunity for undetected theft is much greater."
Create clear, merit-based career advancement pathways for non-family employees to incentivize managerial skill accumulation and performance.
Create merit-based promotion pathways and professional governance boards that allow non-family managers to advance to top executive positions.
"A third reason is the promotion opportunities for managers in developing countries are limited because the top managerial layers in almost all firms are filled by family members of the owner because outsiders are not trusted. This reduces the incentives for mid-level managers to develop their decision-making skills, or for firm owners to train them to make important decisions."
Establish cash-flow-based and competency-evaluated credit programs for emerging entrepreneurs to bypass physical collateral requirements.
"...financing obstacles are likely to limit the extent to which individuals with better managerial talent, but low capital, can start and grow enterprises to compete with badly managed firms. Coupled with the inability of better managed firms to delegate and thus to grow beyond a certain size, this lack of competition from new entrants who are short of financing will keep productivity low..."
Implement localized operational budgets that empower plant managers to immediately purchase critical maintenance parts without upper-management pre-approval.
"This illustrates one problem with hierarchical decision making, which is the large time delays in processing information, leading to losses from unfixed problems."
Expand targeted credit and micro-grant mechanisms for small-scale enterprises where marginal returns on capital injections remain exceptionally high.
Implement targeted micro-grant programs and direct credit allocations to cash-constrained small enterprises to unlock high-return capital investments.
"They found this increased capital stock and firm profits, with an implied real return to capital of five percent per month."
Conduct systematic management awareness audits to benchmark operational workflows against modern industry standards.
Conduct systematic audits of operational workflows against global industry benchmarks to identify unadopted management practices and train plant leaders.
"The initial evidence in BEMMR suggests that one major reason is the firms were simply not aware of many modern manufacturing practices."
Establish standardized accounting and inventory tracking data systems to mitigate managerial theft risks and enable delegation beyond immediate family members.
Establish structured executive governance policies that separate ownership equity from operational delegation to enable professional non-family management.
"Revealingly, the number of brothers and sons of the firm's owner is an excellent predictor of firm size in the BEMMR sample, because the owners trust relatives and so will delegate decisions to them (unlike a professional manager)."
Implement systematic daily defect recording and root-cause analysis protocols on manufacturing production lines.
Establish standardized quality defect measurement logs on production lines and perform weekly root-cause analysis to eliminate recurring operational errors.
"Introducing systems to measure quality defects and analyze the data enabled firms to correct the causes of defects quickly, reducing average defects levels by over 50 percent in the first three months alone."
Grant plant floor managers emergency spending limits for essential machinery spare parts to prevent cascading operational downtime.
"The plant managers did not have the authority to order parts to repair this equipment, and since the owners were often traveling on business, these problems would persist."
Utilize objective third-party operational benchmarking audits to evaluate plant management quality rather than relying on self-reported manager appraisals.
"When asked to evaluate the quality of their own management practices, firm managers typically rate them as above average, suggesting they are unaware of their own deficiencies."
Separate family equity ownership from executive hiring decisions by selecting chief executive officers through competitive, merit-based external recruitment.
"Family firms that pass down the CEO position by primogeniture—to the eldest son—typically perform significantly worse in terms of management practices compared to family firms that hire professional managers."
Dismantle anti-competitive entry barriers and trade protections to force underperforming firms to adopt modern management practices or exit the market.
Reduce import tariffs and trade barriers to expose domestic manufacturing sectors to international product market competition.
"The lower level of average management practices in developing countries occurs because of a persistent, thick tail of badly managed firms. In the United States badly managed firms appear to improve or exit, while in developing countries they do not."
Design internal financial auditing and inventory tracking systems to reduce monitoring costs and theft risks prior to delegating managerial authority.
Establish legal contracts backed by strict internal audit logs and real-time output tracking systems to reduce managerial theft risks before delegating financial authority.
"One is poor rule of law, as the owners typically fear that managers will steal from them if given greater autonomy, and they will not be able to punish them without an effective legal system."
Implement double-blind internal evaluations across plant monitoring, target-setting, and merit-based incentive systems to benchmark operations against global standards.
"They find that developing countries like Brazil, China and India have significantly lower average management scores than firms in the United States, Japan and Western Europe. In fact, the whole distribution of practices across firms in developing countries is typically stochastically dominated by the distribution in rich countries."
Lower import barriers and non-tariff trade restrictions to foster competitive pressures that encourage firms to upgrade operational practices.
"Trade protectionism, through high import tariffs, insulates domestic firms from foreign competition, thereby enabling poorly managed domestic firms to remain profitable and stay in business."