Research steps
Keep financial choices private
- Separate spouses; explain income privacy
- Offer consumption or deposit choices
- Select and pay privately; reunite spouses
Illustrative summary of the described Private condition with a 200 peso endowment and 40 peso show-up fee per participant. A nine-sided die and luck-of-the-draw mechanism implement choices before spouses reunite.
See source →How
When to use
Married individuals in low-income households often face competing personal and family financial priorities. Standard joint decision-making setups expose personal income shocks to spousal monitoring and control. This protocol provides a structured environment where individuals can allocate windfall earnings without spousal observation.
Separate married partners upon arrival at a private testing facility to elicit individual financial allocations under complete information privacy.
- Local researchers separate husbands and wives into individual rooms immediately upon arrival at the laboratory.
- Experimenters inform each subject privately that their spouse does not know whether any income was received or what choices are offered.
- Experimenters endow each participant with 200 pesos in addition to a 40 peso show-up fee.
- Experimenters present participants with choices between committed consumption gift certificates and direct deposit into an account of their choosing.
- Experimenters implement decisions individually using a nine-sided die roll and luck-of-the-draw mechanism to maintain plausible deniability.
- Local staff pay participants individually based on their private choice before reuniting them with their spouses.
Why it works
This allows the non-managing spouse to save funds in personal accounts without facing immediate reallocation or spousal punishment.
Example
Researchers tested 48 married men and 48 married women at Green Bank in Mindanao, Philippines. When given 200 pesos under private conditions, 52 percent of men deposited the money into their own accounts rather than committing it to consumption or turning it over to their wives.
About the study
Participants
146 married couples (291 individuals) recruited near Green Bank in Mindanao, Philippines, with average age of 43 and 19 years married.
Study Design
Randomized field experiment assigning couples to Private, Public, or Negotiation treatment conditions to evaluate financial choices over 200 pesos earnings.
Results
Under Private information, 52 percent of men deposited funds into their own account compared to 23 percent in Public (p-value = 0.002). Men whose wives control savings were 55 percentage points more likely to deposit money into their own accounts in Private.