Try, learn and adjust
Check weekly threshold reward calculations
- Plan: Explain Meena’s assigned 4- or 5-day weekly threshold: 10,000 steps per day and 20 INR per qualifying day only if the threshold is met.
- Try: Collect evening step reports, send immediate progress texts and pay weekly mobile credit. Verify device memory at biweekly visits.
- Learn: Compare Meena’s verified target days, weekly threshold and payment: do they agree?
- Adjust: Keep the calculation process if they agree. Otherwise change how errors are checked before the next weekly payment.
Illustrative: Meena is fictional. School’s suggested learning loop, not the source study’s tested protocol.
See source →School’s suggested, untested loop: observe verified steps, threshold attainment and mobile credit; do not alter assigned thresholds.
How
When to use
Health programs struggle to motivate regular exercise among individuals who experience immediate effort costs and discount future health benefits. Standard linear incentive schemes pay for every day of physical activity but can be costly for program budgets. This method serves adults managing chronic conditions like diabetes who exhibit impatience over physical effort.
Offer financial rewards for daily exercise target compliance conditional on meeting a weekly minimum threshold of active days.
- Assign participants a fixed daily physical activity goal of walking 10,000 steps per day recorded on a pedometer.
- Structure a weeklong payment period with a non-separable threshold rule requiring compliance on a minimum number of days, such as 4 or 5 days per week.
- Establish a daily rate of 20 INR per compliant day, paying out only if the weekly threshold requirement is met.
- Collect step entries through daily automated evening phone calls and deliver immediate SMS feedback on progress toward the weekly threshold.
- Disburse accumulated weekly rewards as prepaid mobile phone credits at the conclusion of each 7-day payment cycle.
- Verify self-reported daily step counts against physical pedometer memory during biweekly home visits.
Why it works
This leverages effort impatience to maintain target compliance while reducing total incentive payout costs by 15 percent relative to linear contracts.
Example
Surveyors delivered weekly threshold contracts requiring 4 or 5 days of 10,000 steps to 1,106 adults with diabetes or high blood sugar in Coimbatore, India. The 5-day threshold contract generated equal overall step target compliance as the linear base case contract while paying out 15 percent less in total financial incentives.
About the study
Participants
1,106 participants in the threshold contract groups in Coimbatore, India, with an average age of 49.56 years, 42 percent female, 67 percent diagnosed diabetic, and an average monthly per capita income of 4,465 INR.
Study Design
A randomized controlled trial comparing time-bundled threshold contracts (4-day and 5-day thresholds paying 20 INR per compliant day if met) against a time-separable linear base case contract and a pedometer-only monitoring group across a 12-week intervention period.
Results
Time-bundled threshold contracts matched the compliance of linear contracts while paying rewards on only 85 percent of compliant days in the 5-day threshold group, reducing payout costs by nearly 15 percent and increasing compliance by 6 percentage points more among participants with above-median effort impatience.