Original source
Do Information Technologies Improve Teenagers’ Sexual Education? Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation in Colombia (2020)
Journal article · The World Bank Economic Review · 34(2), 371–392
Read the source ↗© The Author(s) 2019. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / THE WORLD BANK. All rights reserved.
Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Full source notice
© The Author(s) 2019. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / THE WORLD BANK. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com
Used in these cards
Integrate mandatory web-based learning modules into mandatory core subjects like computer education to enforce platform utilization and tracking.
"To incentivize course completion, each school participating in the course included these grades as a component of the grade of one school subject, typically computer education."
Structure digital health interventions with off-site, anonymous remote counselors rather than local classroom teachers to eliminate social stigma during sensitive Q&A sessions.
"Profamilia's course takes full advantage of Internet connectivity to provide an interactive experience and responsive, anonymous counseling... These features aim to create a safe social environment for adolescents to discuss sensitive topics."
Implement periodic booster activities or peer discussions following main educational courses to sustain attitudinal shifts against post-intervention erosion.
"It also generates a 0.24 improvement in an index of sexual attitudes at course completion, and a 0.17 standard deviation improvement after six months."
Implement comprehensive sexual education and condom access programs without fear of increasing adolescent sexual activity rates.
"The data do not provide evidence that the online course increased sexual activity, which together with the increased condom demand result suggests that the course results in improved sexual practice or at least safe-sex preparedness."
Deploy structured web-based learning software onto pre-existing public school computer infrastructure rather than procuring new hardware to optimize return on capital investment.
"It complements this literature by showing that, once computers have been installed in schools, structured Internet courses-at least for sexual education-can have significant effects."
Assign entire peer cohorts or full intact classrooms to health education interventions rather than selecting scattered individuals, maximizing peer reinforcement.
"However, the analysis provides compelling evidence that treatment effects are enhanced when a larger share of a student's friends also takes the course."
Reallocate public health budgets toward centralized digital learning platforms to lower per-capita costs and achieve benefit-to-cost ratios exceeding 1.5 in adolescent health programs.
"The headline result is that the course averts one STI at a cost of $455, indicating a benefit-to-cost ratio of 1.72, well above one. This implies that the course is socially desirable, even with typical deadweight loss factors due to taxation."
Implement mandatory, interactive web-based health modules monitored by remote counselors within existing school computer labs to standardize instruction and bypass instructor reluctance.
"Information and communication technologies (ICTs) for sexual education hence hold promise to improve school-based sexual education along three dimensions: reducing loss of effectiveness when scaling up, reducing costs of implementation, and overcoming educator reluctance to present sexual education material."
Enroll entire grade-level cohorts rather than a subset of classrooms when deploying school-based health curricula, as information does not passively diffuse across classroom boundaries.
"The results do not provide any indication of classroom-level spillovers within the same school, which suggests for policy purposes that programs should target entire cohorts, not a subset of classrooms with expectations of spillovers leading indirectly to treatment."
Utilize interactive, multi-week web modules with embedded self-testing to establish durable long-term knowledge retention without decay.
"The effects are practically identical at completion of the course and six months later, suggesting little decay in knowledge."
Distribute coded, redeemable vouchers for physical health commodities to objectively verify participant behavioral change in sensitive field evaluations.
"The condom voucher makes it possible to avoid obvious problems with self-reported sexual behavior data, and follows O'Donnell et al. (1995) and Thornton (2008)."
Schedule comprehensive sexual health interventions for 14- to 15-year-old cohorts immediately preceding local median ages of sexual debut to maximize protective knowledge before behavioral initiation.
"Profamilia's course targets 14-15 year olds precisely because they are close to becoming sexually active... On the other hand, sexual education should in principle be provided before sexual initiation to convey its full benefits."
Treat non-overlapping time shifts in shared physical facilities as distinct, independent sampling units when conducting field evaluations in multi-shift public infrastructure.
"Given the lack of interaction among children of different shifts, the study treats different shifts in the sample as different schools."
Administer offline paper-and-pencil evaluations when testing computer-based educational programs to eliminate modality familiarity bias.
"The pencil and paper survey strategy was chosen instead of a computer survey because treatment students would have more familiarity with computers at endline, hence unnecessarily biasing results."