Research procedure
Verify services before monthly bonuses
- Set the assigned service bonus scheme
- Collect monthly service reports; verify independently
- Disburse verified service bonuses monthly
Illustrative summary of the payment procedure. Schemes paid 1,000 SLL per visit to workers, supervisors or each; double shared paid 2,000 SLL each. Control had no piece-rate.
See source →How
When to use
Frontline health personnel often receive fixed monthly stipends regardless of their daily effort or patient volume. This flat payment structure fails to reward workers directly for providing extra health services to rural families. Offering short-term cash piece-rates for completed services provides immediate financial motivation for frontline health workers and supervisors.
Pay direct financial piece-rate bonuses to frontline healthcare workers and supervisors for verified primary care services.
- Establish specific cash payment amounts for each verified primary care service provided to households.
- Assign health workers to track and submit monthly records of household visits and medical services provided.
- Pay frontline health workers 1,000 SLL per completed service visit under worker-targeted incentive schemes.
- Pay peer supervisors 1,000 SLL per worker service visit under supervisor-targeted incentive schemes.
- Split the financial bonus equally at 1,000 SLL each to worker and supervisor under shared incentive schemes.
- Disburse piece-rate cash bonuses monthly following independent verification of submitted service reports.
Why it works
Short-term cash payments supplement long-term career incentives without diminishing worker motivation under promotion tournaments.
Example
In Sierra Leone, researchers cross-randomized four financial piece-rate schemes across peripheral health units covering 2,009 community health workers. Units received either worker incentives (1,000 SLL per visit), supervisor incentives (1,000 SLL per visit), shared incentives (1,000 SLL to each), double shared incentives (2,000 SLL to each), or control (no piece-rate).
About the study
Participants
2,009 Community Health Workers and 372 Peer Supervisors across 372 Peripheral Health Units in Sierra Leone.
Study Design
Randomized controlled trial cross-randomizing four short-term financial piece-rate bonus structures with meritocratic promotion and salary transparency interventions over a 10-month evaluation period.
Results
Short-term piece-rate bonuses increased household health visits, and regression analysis confirmed that financial piece-rate bonus effects operated orthogonally without crowding out long-term meritocratic promotion tournament incentives.