Source · aikyam school

Why Do Skilled Immigrants Struggle in the Labor Market? A Field Experiment with Thirteen Thousand Resumes

Original source

Philip Oreopoulos

Why Do Skilled Immigrants Struggle in the Labor Market? A Field Experiment with Thirteen Thousand Resumes

Journal article · American Economic Journal: Economic Policy · 3(4), 148–171 · Version date: November 2011

Read the source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Discontinue reliance on partial name-anglicization as a individual strategy for overcoming hiring discrimination and adopt structural resume-anonymization policies.

"The callback rate among Type 1 resumes with English first names and Chinese last names... is 12.5 percent, which is significantly different from the callback rate among those with first and last English names... but not significantly different from the callback rate among those with first and last Chinese names."

Policy makers should acknowledge that foreign experience discounting is selectively applied based on source country rather than being a universal penalty against all overseas work.

"Interestingly, the resumes that list only British experience do not generate any significant fall in callback rates compared to Type 0 Canadian resumes (14.1 percent compared to 15.8 percent, as reported in column 5)."

Configure applicant tracking systems (ATS) to automatically strip candidate names, foreign location identifiers, and institutional names prior to initial HR screening.

"One direct policy recommendation that arises from concluding that implicit discrimination drives at least some of the results is that employers should consider masking names on applications before making initial interview decisions."

Human resource departments should institute structured, itemized evaluation rubrics for resume screening to compel evaluators to score specific individual candidate skills rather than making holistic group-based pass/fail decisions.

"Employers who are less accustomed to seeing foreign named or foreign educated applicants with adequate language skills are more likely to lump all foreign named and foreign educated applicants into one category even if there are other listed characteristics that offset the concerns about language skills."

Policy researchers must redesign labor market assimilation models to address permanent structural barriers rather than relying on time-in-country to eliminate immigrant earnings disparities.

"While the immigrant-native wage gap used to disappear (and sometimes even reversed sign) after 10 to 15 years for immigrants arriving prior to the 1970s, wages of immigrants arriving in the 1990s are still about 25 percent lower than wages of non-immigrants even after 2005 (Marc Frenette and René Morissette 2005)."

Replace secondary resume credential building with direct anonymized skill assessments during candidate screening.

"The addition of Canadian references for resumes with all or some foreign experience..., listing permanent residency status..., or attaching accreditation to a foreign degree has no significant impact on raising callback rates among Types 2, 3, or 4 resumes with foreign education and/or experience. The point estimates are all close to zero."

Restructure recruiter performance evaluations to reward objective skill-matching and penalty-free trial assessments rather than punishing rare bad-hire outcomes.

"Some recruiters also pointed out that they often face more pressure to avoid bad hires than they are awarded for exceptional ones. This leads to risk aversion and exacerbates the impact from even small signals of lower expected productivity."

Standardize candidate selection criteria to evaluate gender and ethnic equity across intersectional demographic pairings rather than examining gender in isolation.

"The callback rates for the Toronto and Montreal sample are estimated to be 4.9 percentage points higher for English named females compared to English named males. The premium arises for Type 0 resumes but not the other resume types."

Organizations should implement anonymized or name-masked application processes where candidate contact details are removed during initial resume screening to ensure impartial interview selection.

"Employer contact falls by 4.4 percentage points when switching from a Canadian resume with a common English name to one with a common Chinese, Indian, Pakistani, or even Greek name (15.7 percent to 11.3 percent, respectively)."

Establish standardized global work experience equivalency frameworks and subsidized bridge internships to help skilled immigrants obtain initial host-country work experience.

"Among resumes with foreign names and foreign education, the callback rate climbs from 6.0 percent to 8.5 percent by listing just one previous job with a company located inside Canada rather than outside. Listing all job experience with companies located inside Canada leads to the callback rate increasing further to 11.0 percent."

Hiring departments should adopt a mandatory 3-to-5 minute phone screening step for all candidates who meet baseline technical criteria prior to rejecting resumes based on language skill concerns.

"If employers are interested in a candidate but concerned about the applicant's language skills, they could contact the applicant by telephone to determine whether an interview would be worthwhile... Another implication is to develop hiring policies that involve contacting marginal applicants to initially assess language abilities, when in doubt."

Discontinue relying on multinational employer branding as a primary mechanism for conveying international skill transferability to domestic hiring managers.

"The callback rates for Types 3 and 4 resumes listing experience with international companies (that could instead be used for resumes with Canadian experience) are 0.071 and 0.068, respectively. The callback rates for Types 3 and 4 resumes listing local foreign company names are 0.099 and 0.040, respectively."

Equal opportunity enforcement agencies should expand hiring discrimination audits beyond visible racial minorities to include white ethnic minority groups with non-Anglo surnames.

"Switching applicants' names from English to Greek origins generates lower callback rates by 4.0 percentage points. The callback rate gap between English and Greek names is about the same as it is between English and other ethnic names and significant at the 5 percent level."

Discontinue assuming technical or non-client-facing roles naturally protect ethnic minority applicants from resume screening bias.

"Across a wide range of occupations ranging from computer programmer and web developer, in the lower decile categories of O*NET language and social skills, to receptionist and project manager in higher decile categories, the ratio in callback rates between resumes with English names and ethnic sounding names remains about the same and statistically significant."

Reconfigure point-based immigration policies to require pre-selection credential validation or host-country employer sponsorship before awarding human capital points.

"Conditioning on highest degree completed, therefore, causes the relative wage gap between recent immigrants and non-immigrants to increase, from 36 percent lower wages for immigrants to 48 percent."

Policy makers should reallocate public funding from formal foreign credential evaluation agencies toward direct local workplace bridge programs that provide newcomers with verifiable host-country experience.

"The addition of Canadian references for resumes with all or some foreign experience... listing permanent residency status... or attaching accreditation to a foreign degree has no significant impact on raising callback rates among Types 2, 3, or 4 resumes with foreign education and/or experience."

Controlling for highest degree completed isolates whether lower immigrant earnings stem from educational differences or from lower market returns to foreign background.

Direct feedback from employers reveals the explicit attitudes and unstated assumptions that influence candidate selection.