Original source
Effects of Group Discussion on Hiring Decisions Involving Transgender Workers: Experimental Evidence from India
Evaluation summary
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Frame prejudice measurement studies as routine commercial decision-making tasks with tangible economic stakes to observe authentic behavioral choices.
"The experiment was framed as market research for a grocery delivery service to measure real hiring decisions while minimizing the risk that participants would guess the study's true purpose."
Design incentivized choice experiments that force decision-makers to choose between prejudiced preferences and explicit material payoffs to quantify the economic magnitude of identity bias.
"Participants in the comparison group were willing to forgo items worth nearly twice the median daily per capita food expenditure whereas those in the 3-person discussion arm (group one) were not willing to sacrifice any items, on average."
Organize structured 10-minute peer discussions among majority-group hiring managers prior to candidate selection to activate latent consensus around non-discrimination.
"Compared to individuals in the comparison group that did not take part in group discussions, participants in 3-person discussions (group one) were 17 percentage points more likely to select a transgender individual for their delivery (a 42 percent increase)."
Survey target populations to identify environments where over 90% condemn discrimination in principle despite widespread discriminatory practices, then deploy structured dialogue to bridge the gap.
"Pro-transgender participants spoke up more often, making supportive statements 2.5 times more common than anti-transgender ones. Their arguments were morally persuasive, emphasizing values like opportunity, rights, and equality."
Combine public accountability or transparent decision-making policies with structured verbal deliberation to prevent social observation from reinforcing perceived discriminatory norms.
"Participants in the public but no-discussion arm (group three), were not more likely than the comparison group to hire transgender individuals."
Replace passive legal rights video broadcasts with interactive peer-group dialogue modules in compliance training programs to ensure behavioral persistence beyond one month.
"Participants who were offered the legal rights video and the rights messaging video were 10.3 percentage points (a 23 percent increase) and 5.8 percentage points (a 13 percent increase) more to hire a transgender individual, respectively... On the other hand, participants who viewed transgender rights videos did not discriminate less one month after the intervention."
Include passive audience observers in structured peer deliberation sessions when logistical or time constraints prevent every individual from speaking actively.
"Two participants were randomly selected to discuss and make choices for the group while the third participant listened to the discussion... Participants in the 2-person discussion arm (group two) were 13 percentage points more likely"