Source · aikyam school

Evidence in Labor Market Policies and Implications for Brazil: Job Search Assistance

Original source

Filipe Cavalcanti; Laísa Ratcher; Livia Gouvêa; Luiz Felipe Fontes

Evidence in Labor Market Policies and Implications for Brazil: Job Search Assistance

Policy evidence synthesis · JOI Brazil / Inter-American Development Bank

Search for this source ↗

CC BY 3.0 IGO

Full source notice

Copyright © 2023 Inter-American Development Bank ("IDB"). This work is subject to a Creative Commons license CC BY 3.0 IGO (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/legalcode). The terms and conditions indicated in the URL link must be met and the respective recognition must be granted to the IDB. Further to section 8 of the above license, any mediation relating to disputes arising under such license shall be conducted in accordance with the WIPO Mediation Rules. Any dispute related to the use of the works of the IDB that cannot be settled amicably shall be submitted to arbitration pursuant to the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) rules. The use of the IDB's name for any purpose other than for attribution, and the use of IDB's logo shall be subject to a separate written license agreement between the IDB and the user and is not authorized as part of this license. Note that the URL link includes terms and conditions that are an integral part of this license.

Used in these cards

"The authors then showed that encouraging recipients to create a detailed action plan about their job search process reduced the gap between the intention to apply for job vacancies and the actual number of applications, expanded the range of search channels used by applicants, and led to higher employment levels."

Deploy audited, diversity-recalibrated machine learning matching algorithms within public job placement platforms to automate candidate screening and resume preparation support.

"In an extension, the same authors showed that using a different algorithm increased demographic diversity while keeping hiring rates high."

Implement audited blind screening protocols for initial candidate resume evaluation in public and private recruitment workflows.

"Selection processes that created mechanisms to make it impossible for the hiring firms to know some characteristics of the candidates have increased hiring of underrepresented groups in some cases"

Incorporate hands-on online labor profile creation modules into standard public employment job-readiness workshops.

"Furthermore, an evaluation in South Africa showed that supplementing labor market preparation programs with training about online employment platforms increased the likelihood of participants being employed, mainly because using these tools allowed them to acquire more information about potential employers"

Establish mandatory but moderate job application reporting quotas for unemployment benefit recipients, paired with active monitoring to prevent worker discouragement and sub-optimal job matching.

"For example, an evaluation in the United States showed that conditioning the receipt of unemployment insurance to job search requirements induced a more intensive job search and reduced the length of unemployment insurance receipt (Klepinger et al., 2002)."

Organize targeted job fairs and deploy information campaigns that provide job seekers with comprehensive, cross-sectoral vacancy data and realistic labor market projections.

"Research in Ethiopia revealed that job fairs provided a means to bridge information gaps in the labor market, resulting in enhanced job search and improved employment outcomes for job seekers who had strong misconceptions about their employment prospects."

Embed psychological goal-setting exercises into job counseling sessions to help unemployed individuals build structured search routines and counteract discouragement.

"In addition, an evaluation in Germany showed that teaching innovative behavioral strategies to increase the chance of goal achievement helped increase job applications."

Integrate automated SMS job vacancy alerts into public employment service workflows to push relevant openings directly to job seekers' mobile devices.

"Integrating SMS communication into this PES resulted in modest positive impacts on participants' short-term (2-month) employment, while participation in the traditional non-digital intermediation did not result in any detectable effects."

Structure private job placement procurement contracts to tie service fees to sustained employment retention metrics at 6 and 12 months rather than initial candidate enrollment or immediate placement numbers.

"In France, an evaluation of a counseling program for those at risk of long-term unemployment showed that it was less effective in increasing participants' employability when offered by the private sector. The researchers suggest that the private providers were less effective because the payment structure encouraged them to maximize the number of participants rather than focusing on allocating participants to the most suitable jobs"

Establish data-sharing partnerships with private enterprises and implement administrative tracking indicators across job centers to improve vacancy capture quality and match outcomes.

"Comparing the groups before and after the referral, the authors found that receiving a referral increased the chances of getting a job. However, they also observed a decrease in the salary of those who received a referral in comparison to their previous job."

Integrate standardized skill certification modules and structured reference letter generation tools into public employment service platforms to help job seekers verifiably signal qualifications to employers.

"In South Africa, reference letters increased employment for women, while they had no effect on men. According to the authors, the results suggest that employers were less confident in the skills reported by women, and the reference letters helped correct this bias."

Distribute targeted transit subsidies or cash stipends via public employment centers to low-income unemployed individuals during active search periods.

"In Ethiopia, one evaluation showed that transport subsidies helped youth find better quality work but did not increase overall employment (Franklin, 2018); the study also found that the program reduced worker discouragement."

Linking administrative data enables government agencies to build reliable performance indicators and monitor public employment center efficiency over time.

Algorithms analyze candidate and vacancy data to streamline candidate screening and produce higher quality employer-worker matches.

Anonymizing candidate characteristics prevents hiring firms from relying on implicit biases or demographic discrimination during early evaluation rounds.

Automated SMS alerts expand the pool of information available to job seekers at low cost.

Recalibrating selection algorithms prevents automated systems from reproducing past discrimination patterns.

Job fairs bridge information gaps in the labor market.

Conditioning benefit payments on search activity creates financial incentives for unemployed workers to search more intensively.

Having access to broader labor market information encourages job seekers to adopt a more realistic search approach.

Training job seekers to use online platforms helps them acquire more information about potential employers.

Aligning provider remuneration with job match quality prevents counseling services from prioritizing rapid placements or maximizing participant volume.

Providing structured instructions on application preparation lowers the technical and administrative friction of applying for jobs.