Source · aikyam school

Job Placement and Displacement

Original source

Caitlin Tulloch (Briefcase Author)

Job Placement and Displacement (2013)

J-PAL policy briefcase; summary of an evaluation · J-PAL Policy Briefcase

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Evaluate local labor market vacancy constraints and competition density prior to expanding intensive counseling programs to prevent negative employment spillovers on non-participants.

"Although job seekers who were offered intensive counseling were 2.5 percentage points more likely to be employed in the short run than their peers who lived in the same communities but were not offered counseling, these peers were 2.1 percentage points less likely to have long-term employment than job seekers in areas where intensive counseling was not offered at all."

Structure public employment subcontracting agreements to require minimum enrollment benchmarks and tie financial rewards to long-term permanent job contracts rather than temporary positions.

"Only 35 percent of the treatment group actually enrolled in intensive counseling, so the positive impact for those who enrolled was partially offset by displacement effects among those in the treatment group who did not enroll."

Measure employment policy impacts over multi-year horizons to ensure interventions create sustainable labor market attachment rather than brief search acceleration.

"Individuals in the treatment group found work more quickly than those in the comparison group in the same areas, but these gains disappeared after twelve months."

Evaluate job placement program success using permanent employment contract metrics rather than short-term or temporary placement rates.

"Increases in employment were also driven by job seekers who found fixed-term contracts, and there was no increase in permanent employment contracts. However, all employment gains disappeared after 12 months..."

Design active labor market evaluations using a two-step cluster randomization framework that varies treatment saturation across distinct local market clusters to measure spillover effects.

"The evaluation used a two-step randomization approach: first, randomly assigning the proportion of job seekers who would receive intensive counseling in a given community, and then randomly assigning job seekers in each treated community into the treatment or comparison group."

Measuring employment across several distinct follow-up windows prevents policies from being mislabeled as successful based solely on short-lived temporary placements.

Private agencies are believed to be more agile and efficient at connecting candidates with prospective employers than public agencies.

Filtering participants by age, education level, and unemployment duration ensures that counseling services reach individuals who have foundational qualifications but struggle with job search friction.

Personalized counseling helps job seekers navigate job applications and connects them directly with hiring managers.