Source · aikyam school

Increasing Community College Completion Rates among Low-Income Students: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial Evaluation of a Case Management Intervention

Original source

William N. Evans; Melissa S. Kearney; Brendan C. Perry; James X. Sullivan

Increasing Community College Completion Rates among Low-Income Students: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial Evaluation of a Case Management Intervention (2017)

working paper · National Bureau of Economic Research · NBER Working Paper 24150

Read the source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Full source notice

© 2017 by William N. Evans, Melissa S. Kearney, Brendan C. Perry, and James X. Sullivan. All rights reserved. Short sections of text, not to exceed two paragraphs, may be quoted without explicit permission provided that full credit, including © notice, is given to the source.

Used in these cards

Replace standalone non-credit remedial course sequences with corequisite support models or non-academic case management to prevent early momentum loss.

Separate financial aid approval authority from student mentoring staff by delegating emergency fund determinations to an independent financial coordinator.

Partner with third-party social service agencies to place dedicated social workers on college campuses with caseloads capped below 40:1 to provide proactive mentoring, referrals, and personal crisis management.

Track early cumulative credit velocity as a key intermediate diagnostic metric for long-term degree completion in student support programs.

Identify student loan borrowers who show early signs of academic withdrawal and target them with immediate retention interventions to prevent default-inducing non-completion.

Pair male postsecondary students with gender-matched mentors and structure coaching frameworks to specifically address gender-based differences in advising receptivity.

Reduce institutional student-to-advisor ratios by restructuring advising departments into specialized tiers with capped caseloads for high-risk student populations.

Require student navigators to hold face-to-face meetings averaging at least 40 minutes per month with each assigned client alongside ongoing text and phone communication.

Prioritize direct state funding allocations toward student-facing operational expenditures and support services rather than applying blanket tuition fee reductions.

Require student intake consent and program registration prior to randomization or service assignment to maximize participant engagement and minimize administrative attrition.

Establish mandatory 90-day review cycles for individualized student service plans to maintain structured progress tracking and build disclosure-enabling advisor rapport.

Extend evaluation timelines for relational mentoring programs to at least six semesters before assessing overall program effectiveness or making funding renewal decisions.

Compare multi-faceted intervention proposals against targeted case management alternatives using per-graduate cost metrics rather than focusing exclusively on overall effect sizes.

Design student retention support structures specifically around mitigating short-term financial volatility and shock absorption rather than relying solely on multi-year academic tuition subsidies.

Establish non-academic vulnerability screening during student intake to evaluate employment pressures, childcare availability, and financial fragility before students encounter critical life shocks.

Establish explicit quantitative contact benchmarks—such as mandatory bi-weekly in-person meetings and weekly digital check-ins—for case managers to ensure intervention fidelity.

Structure financial aid policies to combine tuition waivers with emergency non-academic support funds and holistic advisory management.

Target intensive case management resources toward low-income students who maintain baseline academic eligibility but face significant non-academic life disruption risks.

Evaluate educational retention investments using longitudinal workforce earnings differentials rather than restricting fiscal decisions to initial institutional outlay costs.

Condition emergency financial assistance disbursements on mandatory participation in case management advising rather than distributing standalone emergency cash grants.

Enforce a 30-credit upper limit during recruitment to focus intensive case management resources on students who remain at high risk of dropping out.

Establish formal institutional partnerships with external social service non-profits to embed certified social workers directly on college campuses for student support.

Structure early case management benchmarks around institutional retention at the primary community college to ensure foundational credit completion prior to four-year transfer.