Source · aikyam school

Matching Frictions and Distorted Beliefs: Evidence from a Job Fair Experiment

Original source

Girum Abebe; Stefano Caria; Marcel Fafchamps; Paolo Falco; Simon Franklin; Simon Quinn; Forhad Shilpi

Matching Frictions and Distorted Beliefs: Evidence from a Job Fair Experiment (2022)

working paper

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Evaluate active labor market programs by measuring long-term behavioral changes in search strategy and belief calibration rather than evaluating interventions solely on immediate direct match placements.

"This suggests that, beyond slowing down matching, search frictions have a second understudied cost: they entrench inaccurate beliefs, further distorting search strategies and labour-market outcomes."

Administer incentivized two-sided belief elicitation surveys using standardized objective tests (such as Raven's Matrices) alongside true population benchmarks to identify structural expectational gaps between employers and jobseekers.

"Overall, almost 75% of firms overestimate the ability of tertiary-educated jobseekers and about 90% of them overestimate the ability premium associated with tertiary education."

Target wage-information and market-exposure programs specifically toward high-school educated jobseekers who face severe structural expectational misalignments regarding formal entry-level roles.

"The effects on jobseekers are concentrated among those without tertiary education, whose employment prospects improve significantly as a result (permanent employment rates double and formal employment rates increase by almost 50 percent)."

Establish standardized internship bridges or objective workplace competency credentials for young jobseekers to substitute for unavailable formal work experience.

"The most common reason firms report for not hiring more at the fair is 'insufficient work experience' (34% of firms)... half of the jobseekers think that no previous work experience is required for securing a high-skilled job."

Construct synthetic lexicographic preference rankings using baseline survey variables (education, previous occupation, and advertised wages) and execute a Gale-Shapley deferred acceptance algorithm to schedule targeted meetings at job fairs.

"Algorithmic recommendations are also shown to have a strong predictive power: matches suggested by our algorithm are about 200 percent more likely take place than non-suggested matches."

Focus labor market information policies on revealing unobservable quality attributes (such as standardized skill certifications and employer selection thresholds) rather than broadcasting public wage data.

"This suggests that while market participants value and acquire relevant publicly available information, the natural interaction between firms and young jobseekers in the labour market is insufficient for participants to learn key parameters of the matching process that are observed through direct interactions."

Deploy structured multi-counterparty exposure events to induce empirical recalibration of expectations among over-optimistic market participants rather than relying solely on passive advice.

"The intervention generates few hires, but it lowers participants' expectations and causes both firms and workers to invest more in search as predicted by a theoretical model; this improves employment outcomes for less educated jobseekers."

Evaluate whether a target population faces binding floor constraints (such as minimum skill thresholds or reservation wages) and high vacancy costs before implementing information interventions, as sobering information increases effort specifically in unsafe regimes.

"In this regime, for sufficiently low $\mu$, the decrease in $\mu$ causes an increase in search expenditure. Given the relatively high cost of not filling the position ($\kappa \gg 0$)... the pessimism shock makes the firm search more intensely."

Grouping firms by Mahalanobis distance minimizes baseline multidimensional variance between treatment and control arms within industry blocks.

Cluster-based enumeration ensures broad geographic coverage while preventing spatial spillovers between treatment and control groups.

Algorithmic recommendations replace random interactions with targeted pairings that account for heterogeneous employer criteria and worker expectations.

High-frequency phone interviews capture short-term dynamic shifts in search effort without relying on long-term recall.

Simultaneously surveying both employers and jobseekers allows researchers to measure belief accuracy against true benchmark distributions rather than self-reported estimates.

Combining administrative lists across multiple government bodies prevents systemic coverage gaps inherent in single-agency business registers.

Providing dedicated physical booths and printed employer directories reduces search costs and queueing bottlenecks.