Original source
Public works programs and labor market outcomes (2024)
secondary policy synthesis · J-PAL Policy Insight
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Pair temporary public works wage payouts with incentivized formal savings accounts to ensure short-term earnings are converted into durable household assets.
"Participants in PWPs increased their savings or assets compared to nonparticipants in nine of ten studies that examined savings or asset accumulation, measured at least several months after program completion. The extra income gained during the PWP allowed participants to have more savings or assets in the medium and long term."
Design female-focused employment quotas and gender-adapted project tasks within public works initiatives to boost total local labor market participation.
"A few PWPs were particularly beneficial for women, especially in areas with low levels of female employment and limited job opportunities for women. For example, in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, increases in women's employment drove overall increases in participants' likelihood of being employed and in their average number of hours worked."
Set public works wage rates slightly above prevailing market floor rates in large-scale deployments to incentivize private sector wage increases across local economies.
"Though the NREGA program in India increased earnings for participants, 80 percent of this increase came from boosted private sector earnings. NREGA's wage rate likely affected this private sector earning increase, as NREGA paid participants above prevailing market wages."
Screen applicant baseline employment levels prior to enrollment to select individuals with zero competing labor opportunities.
"In the Ivory Coast, for example, the quarter of participants who experienced the greatest program impact saw their short-term earnings increase 2.2 times that of participants in the lowest quarter of program impact."
Calculate net economic program benefits by subtracting estimated foregone private earnings and household labor reductions from total public wage disbursements.
"The increased income experienced by participants usually represented only a fraction of the PWP's overall transfer amount. This suggests that PWP participants often reduced their time spent on other income-generating activities while participating in PWPs."
Assess local liquidity constraints versus distress migration rates before launching public works programs to predict whether regional labor mobility will increase or decrease.
"When researchers tracked participant savings in Comoros, participants' increased resources helped unlock migration opportunities for marginalized groups who would otherwise not be able to afford migration expenses. However, in a quasi-experimental study from India, researchers found that the PWP decreased internal migration using spatial modeling techniques."
Bundle vocational skills training in public works programs with formal savings incentives rather than offering training as an isolated intervention.
"In one evaluation from the Democratic Republic of the Congo, PWP participants who received hard-skills training and an incentivized savings scheme experienced the largest positive impacts on the likelihood of having a job and on savings. However, researchers did not observe the same positive effects for participants who only received the skills training."
Provide basic micro-enterprise management modules alongside cash-for-work wages to help participants re-invest earnings into self-employed micro-businesses.
"In the Democratic Republic of the Congo, PWP participants worked 16 percent more days in self-employment compared to nonparticipants, as measured over a year after the PWP ended."
Incorporate structured employment components into social safety net programs deployed in crisis or refugee settings where psychological distress and social isolation are prevalent.
"Refugees who were randomly assigned to receive a small daily wage in exchange for work experienced strong psychological benefits compared to participants who received the same amount of cash but did not work."
Align temporary public works wage rates closely with local private market floor rates near program conclusion to prevent workers from developing unviable wage expectations.
"In an infrastructure-focused PWP in Tunisia, for example, participants experienced a five percentage point decline in the probability of engaging in any income-generating activity compared to nonparticipants five years after program completion."
Set public works wage rates at or slightly below prevailing market floor rates while requiring physical labor to enforce automatic self-selection by low-income individuals.
"Given PWPs' demanding labor and time commitments, and because PWPs generally pay at or below minimum wage, individuals who have access to alternative income sources should theoretically avoid these cash-for-work programs. In comparison to traditional cash transfer programs, PWPs are thus thought to better target people most in need of financial support."