Original source
Stigma and Take-Up of Labor Market Assistance: Evidence from Two Field Experiments (2023)
Research manuscript
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Apply Imbens-Wooldridge normalized difference checks and balanced sub-sampling when evaluating randomized controlled trials executed through proprietary third-party advertising algorithms.
"On that platform randomization is not directly controlled by the researchers, and we found significant imbalance in the covariates."
Apply agnostic machine learning split-sample validation to estimate Sorted Group Average Treatment Effects before concluding that an economic or social intervention lacks impact.
"Many studies have failed to find much evidence of stigma depressing take-up on average (see Currie (2006) for a survey), but as we show, this may be due to underlying heterogeneity that went undetected."
Audit recruitment interventions using Lasso-based index metrics and machine learning heterogeneity tests rather than evaluating success solely on aggregate participation volume.
"Even if a particular treatment intervention has no average effect on take-up relative to control, it can alter who participates if the effects are heterogeneous."
Avoid using anti-stigma messaging in brief online advertisements, reserving stigma-mitigation campaigns for high-touch, in-person outreach.
"The professional stigma treatment leads to a decrease of 0.032 percentage points, a 26% decrease relative to the control group, and the social stigma treatment leads to a decrease of 0.047, or 39% relative to control."
Apply split-sample machine learning algorithms to baseline data in randomized trials to evaluate subgroup variation instead of performing ad-hoc post-hoc subgroup tests.
"These methods use machine learning algorithms that predict the individual treatment effect for study participants using baseline data on others in the sample. This ensures that the estimated individual treatment effects are not merely a form of data-mining, but are in fact 'honest'."
Measure recruitment-stage eligibility and non-applicant drop-off when evaluating active labor market policies rather than restricting randomization to existing applicant pools.
"There is a third group to consider, however: those who were eligible but never applied due to the method of recruitment. Estimates of the treatment effects in such a case may not be valid for this third group, and various types of stigma may explain why they are not in the sample."
Reframe active labor market program outreach to focus on occupational growth and employer prestige rather than attempting to destigmatize the financial subsidies of the training program.
"Our results suggest that in some contexts the stigmas surrounding program outcomes (e.g., entry-level jobs) may be more important than stigma surrounding program participation itself."
Focus labor market recruitment messages on external social respect and professional advancement rather than internal job satisfaction metrics.
"On the other hand, we do not find any evidence of heterogeneity in the effects of the personal stigma treatment."
Explicitly align recruitment messaging with program goals: use stigma-mitigation messaging if maximizing post-training employment returns is the primary goal, but avoid it if strict poverty targeting is required.
"In our experiments, the treatments designed to alleviate stigma delivered applicants to the program who were generally richer, older, and more likely to be already working... In this case, a policy maker focused on impacts may find these interventions worthwhile, while one focused on the poor would not."
Allocate recruitment budgets toward mitigating non-monetary social frictions rather than funding cash attendance stipends once program fees are waived.
"We found that application rates decrease with price but do not increase with the incentive."
Disaggregate recruitment communications into distinct tracks addressing immediate social approval versus long-term career advancement rather than combining them into a single general stigma message.
"The social stigma effect is significantly larger than the professional stigma effect at the 5% level, suggesting that these two stigmas are distinct phenomena."
Focus public policy communications on elevating job title prestige and career growth trajectory rather than masking or hiding benefit subsidy eligibility.
"Telling recruits that the program is subsidized 'to help those in financial hardship' has no significant effect on application rates or program composition, and we do not find significant evidence of heterogeneity in these effects."
Design program recruitment pitches that lead directly with positive testimonials and growth data, eliminating any explicit framing that highlights society's negative judgment.
"This confirms that our mitigation attempts in Experiment 1 did help dispel some stigma concerns but were often outweighed by the negative salience effects. This shows the need for care in attempts to dispel stigma, since overall impacts will depend on the combination of the salience effect and the mitigation effect."
Measure baseline societal norm perceptions prior to launching employment interventions to quantify the exact proportion of the target population constrained by occupational stigma.
"First, we show that there is belief among a sizeable minority of young Egyptian jobseekers that there are negative stigmas surrounding entry-level jobs. For example, 43% of jobseekers acknowledge that many people in society look down on these jobs."
Target stigma-reframing job campaigns specifically toward candidates who possess baseline status buffers rather than relying on uniform population outreach.
"The treatments generally deliver wealthier applicants; these may be people who are less concerned about how their job affects their social standing, because they have other sources of high status that allows them to withstand any serious negative consequences from engaging in this type of labor market assistance."
Audit informational interventions using baseline-controlled ANCOVA specifications to verify that non-monetary behavioral nudges do not inadvertently distort financial return expectations.
"This undertaking confirms that our treatments act on beliefs about stigma and do not change beliefs about monetary returns."
Measure subjective wage expectations alongside social status beliefs in pilot recruitment surveys to verify that messaging interventions operate purely on social image channels rather than financial perception channels.
"The results from our survey experiment clearly establish two things: first, that stigmas surrounding entry-level jobs exist, and second, that our treatment affects people's perceptions of stigma and not their monetary expectations of the jobs."
Structure recruitment communications to highlight career advancement and positive alumni role models while completely avoiding language that names or frames social judgments and stigmas.
"Making stigma concerns more salient by including them in the script leads to a negative effect on application rates for basically everyone in the sample and has a very strong negative effect on 'bottom group'. When we provide data and testimonials to try to dispel the stigma concerns, the significant negative effects disappear."
Define explicitly whether a labor policy prioritizes equity or impact efficiency before launching anti-stigma messaging campaigns in recruitment drives.
"In our experiments, the treatments designed to alleviate stigma delivered applicants to the program who were generally richer, older, and more likely to be already working. These are likely not those with the most financial need."
Audit job recruitment materials to ensure career mobility messaging directly addresses long-term professional advancement rather than relying solely on personal satisfaction claims.
"We find a large and statistically significant difference in the effects on the top and bottom group for professional stigma (p=0.015). On the other hand, we do not find any evidence of heterogeneity in the effects of the personal stigma treatment."