Original source
Stopping a Bullet with a Summer Job
J-PAL policy briefcase; synthesis of evaluations · J-PAL Policy Briefcase
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Structure youth employment interventions around experiential skill formation rather than relying on physical monitoring to achieve durable crime reductions.
"If summer jobs programs merely kept youth busy during the summer, the bulk of the violence reductions should not have occurred after the programs ended."
Disaggregate program evaluation metrics by specific crime category to isolate distinct psychological and financial behavioral mechanisms.
"Although the OSC+ program did not reduce nonviolent crime, and researchers found suggestive evidence of an increase in property crime, it is not uncommon for interventions to impact violence-which by nature involves conflict-differently from other crime outcomes."
Separate policy expectations for summer youth employment, treating them as targeted behavioral and safety interventions rather than standalone long-term career development solutions.
"Besides a small effect in the year after the program summer, SYEP participation did not help youth find jobs in subsequent years."
Deploy subsidized minimum-wage summer employment programs for high-risk youth that incorporate workplace-based social-emotional skill practice to reduce post-program violent behavior.
"Across the 2012 and 2013 cohorts, participating in OSC+ reduced the number of violent crime arrests one year after random assignment by 6.4 arrests per 100 youth, from a baseline of 18.3 arrests per 100 youth (a 35 percent reduction). The bulk of this decline occurred after the program ended."
Allocate municipal public safety funds toward low-cost subsidized summer job lotteries to maximize monetized societal return on investment.
"Researchers estimate that the social benefits from the reduction in violence from the OSC+ program may be nearly six times larger than the program's costs."
Implement large-scale lottery-allocated summer youth jobs programs to reduce long-term mortality and incarceration among economically disadvantaged teenagers.
"SYEP participation between 2005 and 2008 reduced the probability that youth would serve time in prison by 2013 by 0.10 percentage points, a 10 percent reduction from the baseline incarceration rate of 0.99 percent, which translated into 112 fewer youth imprisoned."