Source · aikyam school

The Effects of Youth Employment on Crime: Evidence from New York City Lotteries

Original source

Judd B. Kessler; Sarah Tahamont; Alexander M. Gelber; Adam Isen

The Effects of Youth Employment on Crime: Evidence from New York City Lotteries (2021)

NBER working paper · NBER Working Paper 28373

Read the source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Full source notice

© 2021 by Judd B. Kessler, Sarah Tahamont, Alexander M. Gelber, and Adam Isen. All rights reserved. Short sections of text, not to exceed two paragraphs, may be quoted without explicit permission provided that full credit, including © notice, is given to the source.

Used in these cards

1. Structure summer youth employment programs with randomized lotteries specifically targeted at youth with prior arrest records to achieve immediate summer crime reduction.

1. Schedule youth employment program hours explicitly during historical peak crime hours (afternoon and early evening weekdays) to maximize incapacitation benefits.

1. Establish non-carceral youth development programs as institutional touchpoints to prevent initial legal system processing and downstream sentence escalation.

1. Target employment programs specifically at communities facing high rates of violent and property felony offenses to capture maximum social welfare gains.

1. Design youth employment program benchmarks around first-time arrest prevention targets rather than repeat-offender frequency reduction.

1. Combine exact deterministic matching tiers with validated probabilistic matching algorithms when linking administrative records lacking universal identifiers.

1. Utilize administrative randomized selection lotteries as instruments when evaluating oversubscribed public interventions to isolate unconfounded causal parameters.

1. Supplement short-term summer jobs programs with multi-year continuous supportive programming to sustain long-term crime reduction outcomes.

1. Utilize municipal youth development agencies as primary community contact nodes for at-risk youth instead of relying on juvenile justice surveillance networks.

1. Maintain a baseline proportion of low-risk peers in youth employment interventions to preserve constructive social norms and prevent negative peer spillover effects.

1. Allocate program slots and recruitment outreach preferentially to individuals with prior criminal justice contact rather than relying on broad universal lotteries.

1. Incorporate subgroup-specific crime cost valuations into government cost-benefit models to justify targeted social program investments.

Randomized selection prevents favoritism and subjective screening in allocating scarce employment slots.

Attending job readiness workshops equips youth with workplace norms while occupying program hours in a structured learning environment.

Weighting averted arrests by specific offense types accounts for large differences in social damage between minor and serious crimes.

At-risk youth face higher baseline rates of criminal justice involvement, providing greater opportunity for program structure to prevent crime.