Original source
Anonymity or Distance? Job Search and Labour Market Exclusion in a Growing African City
Dated research draft · Version date: 19 August 2018
Search for this source ↗Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Used in these cards
Deploy short, two-day standardized testing and signaling workshops instead of high-cost vocational training programs to improve youth employment outcomes at scale.
"The job application workshop generates an average wage gain of USD 10 per month per worker, for a one-off cost of USD 18.20 per individual. This compares favourably to other available labour market interventions..."
Apply conservative differential mean and standard deviation imputation bounds to longitudinal trial data to confirm treatment effect robustness against attrition.
"However, we are able to estimate economically large and statistically significant effects of the workshop in the large majority of cases. For instance, the size of the effect is above 10 percent of the control group mean in all simulations but one."
Prioritize low-cost informational and skill-certification workshops over capital-intensive transit subsidies or lengthy vocational training in ALMP budgeting.
"Second, this intervention is unusually cheap (high-impact interventions tend to be training programs that cost several hundred dollars per participant). As a result, the ratio of the monthly earning gains to the marginal one-off cost is unusually high for this intervention."
Group continuous applicant assessment scores into discrete performance bands on credentials to leverage threshold signaling effects for job-seekers.
"We find that being placed in a higher band generates a large, but noisily estimated increase in wages in 2018... the effect is consistently between 0.2 and 0.3 standard deviations and is significant at the 10 percent level when we use the larger bandwidth."
Implement early-career placement assistance that prioritizes secure, contract-backed formal employment over immediate temporary placement to prevent career scarring.
Target youth active labor market policies specifically toward placing job-seekers into permanent contracts rather than temporary stopgap jobs to prevent career scarring.
"Most strikingly, having any job after one year is not correlated with earnings at all after controlling for having a permanent or formal job. That is, individuals who had temporary or informal jobs after year do not have higher earnings that those that were unemployed."
Incorporate split-sample endogenous stratification into program evaluations to measure whether labor interventions systematically compress inequality between high- and low-potential workers.
Stratify target populations by predicted baseline earnings to deliver skill-signaling tools specifically to low-predicted-earning youth.
"The estimated effect size for the low-predicted-earnings group is about 50% of the control mean. This causes a large reduction in earning inequality: the earning gap between the low and the high earnings group drops from 142 percent to 54 percent..."
Issue standardized, low-variance skill assessment scorecards to job applicants to eliminate productivity uncertainty for risk-averse employers during interview screening.
"The key insight from this model is that tightening signals over workers' ability increases match quality and therefore wages, as long as the firm is risk neutral or moderately risk averse."
Implement early-career skill certification interventions to help youth secure permanent formal contracts rather than relying on aggregate GDP growth to raise wages.
"Average wages in the control group grew at roughly the rate of inflation, during a period when the economy was growing at 8% per year. This lack of wage growth appears to be related to the inability to find stable work."
Structure high-frequency panel questionnaires using identical baseline wording and non-directional prompts to avoid inducing behavioral measurement artifacts among study participants.
"Franklin (2017) shows that high-frequency phone surveys of this type are reliable, in the sense of not generating Hawthorne effects."
Deploy bi-weekly short phone questionnaires alongside annual face-to-face surveys to track fine-grained behavioral responses to labor market policies.
"Fourth, we combine face-to-face survey data with a high-frequency phone questionnaire. This enables us to document the mechanisms through which job-seekers find better jobs and to analyse their immediate response to each intervention in a way that recall data would not permit."
Encourage early career job mobility and credential portability so young workers can leverage market switches rather than relying solely on internal firm promotions.
"Only about 13 percent of workers hold the same job that they had at the first endline, three years before. Further, treated workers have not been employed in their current job for longer than control workers... These findings underscore the importance of job mobility for wage growth"
Prioritize formal wage-employment matching programs over self-employment subsidies when designing active labor market policies for urban youth.
"when asked what kind of work they were looking for, 64% said they were looking specifically for a permanent job, whereas only 25% reported they were applying to jobs without consideration for the contract type. Only 5.4% of respondents said that they were trying to start their own business"
Establish standardized skill certification mechanisms specifically targeted at non-tertiary high school graduates to bridge the formal employment gap caused by educational segmentation.
"For instance, a worker with tertiary education is seven times more likely to have a permanent job and four times more likely to have a formal job than a worker who has only completed high school."
Provide targeted cash liquidity transfers during active job hunting periods to prevent credit-constrained job-seekers from accepting sub-optimal, low-wage stopgap jobs.
"When resources for job search are exhausted, credit constrained job-seekers are forced to accept poorly-matched jobs."
Provide standardized multi-dimensional competence testing to job candidates to lower evaluation noise for prospective employers during hiring decisions.
"First, treated young people stay in the same job for a longer period of time. Employment duration is often considered a key indicator of match quality as it is evidence that both the firm and the employee value the match."
Disaggregate applicant evaluations into independent skill category certificates (e.g., cognitive reasoning, linguistic accuracy, data entry speed) rather than releasing a single aggregate GPA or score.
"Indeed, 44% of workers score in the top band for at least one skill and only 10% of workers are in the lower half of the distribution for all skills. Further, we find that earnings in the treatment group strictly stochastically dominate earnings in the control."
Vary the geographic density of treatment assignment across intervention clusters to isolate indirect peer effects and social network information transmission from direct policy impacts.
"We document a positive indirect effect on formal and permanent work among control individuals in clusters with 40 percent saturation. We also document that untreated individuals in clusters with 90 percent saturation are 5.6 percentage points less likely to be in permanent employment than individuals in pure control clusters."
Aggregate related secondary survey metrics into standardized domain indices and control False Discovery Rates across the resulting super-family of indices.
"In addition to investigating each outcome in a family separately, we use a standard 'omnibus' approach: we construct an index for each family and test whether the index is affected by our treatments... we report both p values and false discovery rate q-values by treating each index as a separate member of a 'super-family' of indices."
Design multi-tiered categorical certification bands that clearly delineate candidate performance thresholds to maximize employer trust and signaling impact.
"We find that being placed in a higher band generates a large, but noisily estimated increase in wages in 2018... being just above the cut-off leads to large increase in earnings of 0.33 standard deviations..."
Implement cluster-based randomized saturation designs to audit local labor market displacement before scaling youth employment policies.
"We find no difference between untreated individuals living in geographical clusters assigned to one of the two interventions and untreated individuals in pure control clusters."
Shift active labor market policy design from encouraging raw job search volume toward equipping applicants with objective skill certification.
"The job application workshop, on the other hand, does not affect the likelihood of searching for a job or the number of job applications sent... In the short run it increases the probability of permanent and formal work without increasing the intensity of job search."
Distinguish search volume metrics from application-to-offer conversion rates when evaluating whether labor market constraints stem from spatial search costs or information asymmetries.
"The job application workshop, on the other hand, does not affect the likelihood of searching for a job or the number of job applications sent... Indeed, in Table A.18 we show that the workshop improves the conversion rates of job applications to job offers..."
Construct skill certification tools that explicitly reduce candidate signal variance across multiple operational skill dimensions to satisfy risk-averse employer screening thresholds.
"...a treatment reducing the noise of an applicant's signal will enable the firm to make a better assessment of the applicant's suitability for the job compared to other candidates. This will increase the expected value of a match for the firm, and increase the expected wage."
Establish standardized third-party skill certification programs evaluating cognitive, mathematical, linguistic, and practical work-sample abilities for unemployed youth.
"We show that helping young job-seekers to signal their skills to employers can generate large and persistent improvements in labour market outcomes."
Administer standardized cognitive and non-cognitive skill testing sessions to young job-seekers and issue official, certified performance bands for job application portfolios.
"Four years later, the workshop significantly increases earnings, job satisfaction and employment duration, while the effects of the transport subsidy have dissipated. These gains are concentrated among groups who generally have worse labour market outcomes."
Distribute temporary transit vouchers targeted at peripheral job-seekers seeking rapid initial placement in formal urban vacancies.
"In other words, lowering the search cost gets young workers a formal job faster, but it does not change their long-term employment outcome."
Establish decentralized physical or digital vacancy notice boards across urban peripheries to lower transit barriers for remote job-seekers.
"among individuals in the control group, living 10 km closer to the centre of the city is associated with visiting the job boards 6.7 more times in a year (0.4 of a standard deviation) and making 1.9 more applications to permanent jobs (0.5 of a standard deviation)."
Provide objective, standardized skill assessment credentials to candidates from disadvantaged backgrounds to override negative statistical stereotyping by employers.
"the condition shows that a reduction in noise is valued by applicants who (i) are a strong match (that is, higher $x_{if}$), and (ii) who have a worse observable (that is, lower $z_i$)."
Deploy objective third-party skill evaluations specifically for job applicants from non-tertiary and inexperienced backgrounds to neutralize employer screening stereotypes.
"The long-run earning impact of the workshop is similarly concentrated among workers with the worst labour market prospects, i.e., those with the least education and experience."
Provide temporary, conditional travel vouchers to unemployed youth to cover commuting expenses to centralized job vacancy boards during active job-hunting periods.
"We find confirmation that search costs are a significant barrier to job search. However, in our representative sample these effects are weak and ultimately short lived."
Avoid funding passive job fairs or physical matching events unless they incorporate standardized candidate skill assessment and certification mechanisms.
"Our analysis of that job fair intervention reveals that job-fairs have no significant impacts on employment and earnings but can help correcting biased beliefs on the part of firms and workers regarding the composition of the labour force"