Source · aikyam school

Evidence in Labor Market Policies and Implications for Brazil: Informality

Original source

André Mancha; Filipe Cavalcanti; Laísa Rachter; Livia Gouvêa; Luiz Felipe Fontes

Evidence in Labor Market Policies and Implications for Brazil: Informality

secondary evidence synthesis · JOI Brazil / Inter-American Development Bank

Read the source ↗

CC BY 3.0 IGO

Full source notice

Copyright © 2025 Inter-American Development Bank ("IDB"). This work is subject to a Creative Commons license CC BY 3.0 IGO (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/legalcode). The terms and conditions indicated in the URL link must be met and the respective recognition must be granted to the IDB. Further to section 8 of the above license, any mediation relating to disputes arising under such license shall be conducted in accordance with the WIPO Mediation Rules. Any dispute related to the use of the works of the IDB that cannot be settled amicably shall be submitted to arbitration pursuant to the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) rules. The use of the IDB's name for any purpose other than for attribution, and the use of IDB's logo shall be subject to a separate written license agreement between the IDB and the user and is not authorized as part of this license. Note that the URL link includes terms and conditions that are an integral part of this license.

Used in these cards

Offer one-time direct cash transfers equal to 1-2 months of average business profit to informal micro-enterprises upon verified formal registration.

"In Sri Lanka, researchers found that providing a monetary transfer to informal firms (equivalent to one or two months of their median profit) in exchange for registration led to greater formalization"

Pair startup registration simplification reforms with targeted productivity-enhancing services to effectively convert established informal firms.

"The results suggest that the reform increased the number of registered companies. This increase resulted from former salaried workers deciding to start their businesses. After the reform, pre-existing informal business owners were no more likely to register their companies."

Legally define flexible working hour arrangements and remote option clauses within formal employment contracts to retain female workers.

"Therefore, offering more flexible formal jobs, with the option of adjusting working hours and remote working, could encourage women to leave the informal sector."

Combine female enterprise formalization incentives with subsidized childcare services and secure personal savings mechanisms to insulate business revenues from household claims.

"In Benin and Malawi, researchers found that women formalized their businesses less or did not formalize them after programs to encourage formalization... women face the challenge of balancing their entrepreneurial activities with domestic responsibilities, which reduces their likelihood of expanding their businesses."

Conduct targeted physical in-person labor inspections to increase the perceived risk and cost of non-compliance among informal employers.

"In Brazil, researchers found that in-person inspections increased formalization."

Implement simplified single-tax registration regimes with reduced social security contribution rates for self-employed entrepreneurs to lower formalization barriers.

"Two quasi-experimental evaluations suggest that the changes introduced by this program led to an increase in formalization between 2009 and 2015."

Deploy trained government agents to perform direct, face-to-face visits offering customized administrative assistance and documentation support to informal enterprise owners.

"In Brazil, informal entrepreneurs in Rio de Janeiro who received in-person individualized assistance increased their formalization and tax compliance after the intervention. However, providing the same information and assistance via instant messaging did not generate any impact on these measures."

Bundle initial business formalization with access to government procurement contracts, commercial loans, and enterprise growth support to ensure high registration renewal rates.

"However, this effect was not maintained over time, mainly because formalized firms decided not to renew their registration, which suggests that firms did not benefit from leaving informality."

Expand public secondary and vocational education infrastructure to raise baseline worker qualifications for formal sector employment.

"Using a theoretical model calibrated with real data, they argue that the increase in schooling was the primary mechanism for increasing formalization in this period."

Design social protection transfers with gradual benefit roll-offs or universal coverage guarantees that persist regardless of formal employment status.

"The results suggest that this policy disincentivized the beneficiaries of the program from formalizing their employment in the labor market."

Implement subsidized technical and vocational training curricula aligned directly with high-demand formal sector occupations.

"In Brazil and Peru, training programs increased the likelihood of their participants working formally, which indicates that these programs can create a pathway for increasing the quality of employment of their participants"

Restrict high-value formalization subsidies and business development grants to informal firms meeting baseline revenue, worker headcount, or banking asset thresholds.

"In Brazil, researchers have shown that the average effect of a formalization incentive program was driven entirely by high-income entrepreneurs (Rocha et al., 2018). The authors argue that this result is consistent with the view that smaller, low-productivity firms benefit little from formalizing."

Issue official, targeted written notifications to unregistered enterprises explicitly outlining legal registration mandates and non-compliance penalties.

"In Bangladesh, researchers randomized informal firms to receive a notification that they need to be registered and about the consequences of not concluding their registration with the competent authority. They found that this notification increased the proportion of registered firms"

Separate municipal business registration from tax agency databases to allow informal firms to obtain legal status before incurring tax liabilities.

"In Malawi, researchers found that companies demonstrated a higher demand for business registration when separated from tax obligations"

Lowering entry costs and administrative delays encourages individuals to launch registered formal businesses instead of remaining in salaried jobs or launching informal enterprises.

Providing work schedule flexibility allows women to reconcile domestic responsibilities with formal employment.

Combining business management education, banking access, and tax mediation increases the tangible benefits of operating legally while mitigating the administrative fears associated with formalization.

Direct physical inspections increase the perceived probability of detection and raise the expected financial cost of non-compliance.

Simplifying administrative requirements and lowering compliance costs makes operating legally affordable for self-employed workers.

Direct financial compensation directly offsets the immediate upfront costs and uncertainty associated with entering the formal system.

Providing free childcare relieves mothers of constant domestic care duties during the workday.

Raising the average educational attainment of the workforce increases worker productivity.

Job training enhances worker technical capabilities and productivity, making participants more attractive to formal employers.

High-productivity firms possess the financial capacity to absorb legal compliance costs and benefit from formal market opportunities.

Removing mandatory tax obligations from the initial registration process lowers the immediate financial risk of obtaining legal status.

Explicit written warnings increase an entrepreneur's belief regarding the likelihood of being detected and penalized.