Source · aikyam school

Market access: Connecting firms and entrepreneurs to markets to spur business and job growth

Original source

Ying Gao

Market access: Connecting firms and entrepreneurs to markets to spur business and job growth (2024)

secondary policy synthesis · J-PAL Policy Insights

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Assess and screen public officials for specialized managerial and commercial competencies before deploying them to lead international trade promotion offices.

"While opening a new export office in a given country usually increased Korean firms' exports for many years, thus helping the country's manufacturing firms grow, there was no positive effect when less-skilled officials were in charge."

Reallocate private sector development funding from standalone supply-side managerial training toward demand-side market access interventions that connect small firms directly to institutional and foreign buyers.

"However, these interventions have had modest effects on firm growth and job creation. This suggests that firms face constraints on the demand side, that is, lacking buyers of their goods and services, which limit growth."

Pair digital platform infrastructure investments with specialized seller visibility tools, quality signaling features, or local aggregator intermediaries to ensure small vendors capture direct financial gains from digital market access.

"While randomized evaluations of transport infrastructure are uncommon, three recent evaluations of digital markets suggest that access to digital marketplaces had limited benefits for small firms on the platform in terms of revenue, profits, or workers' income."

Implement verified seller quality badges and algorithmic search visibility boosts for high-quality small manufacturers participating in public or commercial digital marketplaces.

"For example, improving small T-shirt exporters' visibility and how they signal product quality to potential buyers on a global e-commerce platform helped the firms to grow sales."

Promote foreign direct investment and market access interventions in female-labor-intensive export manufacturing sectors to expand formal economic opportunities for women.

"In a quasi-experimental study in Myanmar, exporting also increased female empowerment as more jobs became available for women and domestic violence dropped in nearby communities."

Form and subsidize female-only SME export consortia to enable women entrepreneurs to pool resources, share market information, and access international buyers.

"Female entrepreneurs are also more likely to lack business contacts-creating peer networks allowed them to expand business networks in Ghana and Tunisia."

Deliver specialized managerial training focused on contract bidding techniques, tender proposal preparation, and formal buyer negotiation strategies to small business owners.

"Three years later, a quarter of these firms were more likely to be operating and employing slightly more workers."

Establish structured peer networking groups and digital messaging networks for local business owners operating in the same geographic market to enable direct contact sharing and collaboration.

"Connecting firms in the same geographic markets with their peers (horizontal links) can similarly improve business performance by allowing firms to gain useful information and contacts from each other and team up for new business collaborations."

Design value-chain technical training programs that co-enroll small agricultural producers alongside commercial export buyers to facilitate contract formation and quality adoption.

"After the training, the producers who were trained together with exporting firms were more likely to have contract-based sales, which tend to have higher prices, and were more likely to use the improved practices."

Establish structured export facilitation programs that pair small domestic manufacturers directly with foreign buyers who provide iterative technical feedback during contract fulfillment.

"In Egypt, offering small rug makers a chance to export rugs to clients in the United States and Europe increased firms' profits by 16-26 percent."

Form buyer alliances among multinational corporations to mandate and directly monitor joint occupational safety and health committees in local supplier facilities.

"In Bangladesh, multinational firms helped enforce laws and improved worker safety at local supplier firms. In this case, multinational buyers formed an alliance to encourage the implementation of legally required workplace safety committees in supplier factories."

Implement national match-making and procurement programs that connect small and medium enterprises directly as suppliers to multinational corporations operating within the host country.

"In Costa Rica, a quasi-experimental study found that after SMEs began supplying to multinational corporations, they were likely to employ more workers, sell more to other firms, and achieve higher productivity four years later."

Provide targeted matching and subsidy programs that assist small business owners in outsourcing specialized marketing and sales tasks to skilled external professionals.

"In Nigeria, helping firms hire or outsource skilled marketing professionals also improved their marketing practices, and it was cheaper than providing business consulting."

Screen applicant firms for minimum operational scale and production capacity before admitting them to government export assistance and commercial trade seminars.

"Only larger firms in the Vietnam example exported more afterward, suggesting that even though smaller firms had access to the same information through the training, they did not have enough production capacity or product quality to start exporting."

Provide small and medium business owners with transparent performance data and objective information regarding public procurement auditing to dispel false corruption perceptions and increase tender participation.

"How well firms trust the government also matters: in Uganda, improving firms' perceptions about government corruption led firms to bid on and win more government tenders."

Leveraging collective buyer purchasing power creates strong economic incentives for local supplier managers to obey national labor laws.

How well firms trust public institutions directly impacts their willingness to invest time and resources in bidding for public contracts.

Giving small firms more resources to produce goods does not lead to sustained growth if there are no customers to buy them.

Digital markets lower connection costs across wide geographic areas, facilitating overall commerce and benefiting consumers and larger traders.

Providing women with high-quality job opportunities outside the household increases their financial independence and economic bargaining power.

Direct communication and repeat feedback from foreign clients transfer technical knowledge and quality standards to local producers.

Training small firm managers in contract bidding and marketing skills reduces informational frictions that prevent small businesses from finding and securing formal commercial buyers.

The administrative implementation quality and skill level of public officials directly determine whether export promotion activities generate real commercial outcomes.

Outsourcing marketing duties allows business owners to access specialized sales expertise without spending time learning complex promotional skills themselves.

Training producers together with exporting buyers builds mutual trust and aligns market quality expectations across the value chain.

Vertical supply chain ties with large multinational buyers drive a process of growth and learning that increases smaller firms' sales and productivity.

Improving platform visibility and product quality signaling reduces search and information frictions between small exporters and foreign buyers.

Generic export information cannot overcome fundamental supply-side constraints like insufficient factory scale or poor product quality.