Source · aikyam school

Labor Supply and the Value of Non-Work Time: Experimental Estimates from the Field

Original source

Alexandre Mas; Amanda Pallais

Labor Supply and the Value of Non-Work Time: Experimental Estimates from the Field (2018)

working paper

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Calculate effective marginal wages in discrete job offerings using the formula $e = \frac{h_2 w_2 - h_1 w_1}{h_2 - h_1}$ to isolate true hourly compensation for incremental work hours.

"We randomly varied the additional earnings an applicant would receive from working the longer job instead of the shorter job. Specifically, we define $e_{ih}$ as the additional earnings for each of the five extra hours in the longer job."

Restrict sample selection to unemployed jobseekers when estimating pure leisure and home production values, or explicitly control for secondary employment wage rates when evaluating employed workers.

"On the other hand, for employed jobseekers, MVT may include not only the value of leisure and household production, but also the wage in another job if workers substitute hours between jobs."

Implement mixture choice models incorporating empirical error recall rates to verify whether cognitive noise distorts structural economic parameters.

"We estimate $2\hat{\alpha}=10.6\%$ using the fraction of applicants who incorrectly recalled their job choice later in the application... inattention-corrected estimates give similar results."

Estimate the baseline opportunity cost of full-time employment for unemployed jobseekers by multiplying their predicted pre-tax market wage by 0.58.

"For unemployed applicants, the average opportunity cost of a full-time job due to lost leisure and household production is approximately 60% of their after-tax marginal product, and approximately 72% when including fixed costs of employment and child care costs."

Apply separate elasticity parameters when evaluating wage policies, utilizing an elasticity greater than 1.0 for part-time/low-hour workers and an elasticity of 0.5–0.6 for full-time workers.

"Below 30 work hours the elasticity of hours with respect to the wage is greater than 1. At or above 40 hours it is in the 0.5-0.6 range."

Constrain logit choice model intercepts using linear regressions of baseline choice probabilities when extrapolating high-wage discrete choice parameters.

"In the '40 vs. 45 Hours' and '45 vs. 50 Hours' panels, we constrain the intercepts, $Pr(1[h_i]=1|e_{ih}=0)$, to values predicted using the estimated intercepts at lower hour treatments... dramatically increasing precision."

Model part-time employment participation using non-linear labor supply curves rather than assuming structural employer-side hour rigidity mandates.

"There are relatively few part-time workers because intermediate hours are on the elastic part of the labor supply curve, implying a limited wage range where a worker would find it optimal to work part-time."

Validate hypothetical choice experiment designs by benchmarking stated preference estimates against field-experimental revealed preference parameters.

"We get similar estimates when we weight the sample to match the characteristics of hourly workers in the United States and when we use a hypothetical choice experiment in the nationally-representative Understanding America Study (UAS)."

Calibrate macroeconomic search and matching models by setting the opportunity cost parameter $z$ to 0.72 for unemployed workers when factoring in fixed employment costs and taxes.

"Our preferred estimate after accounting for these additional costs is z=0.72 which is in the intermediate to higher range of values used in the search literature."

Validate complex pricing or wage experimental designs by testing whether presenting options as total average rates versus incremental marginal rates yields identical structural parameter choices.

"The estimates are close and we conclude that the framing of the choice is not influencing the estimated MVT."

Matching the covariate distribution of a nationally representative benchmark adjusts for demographic composition differences between the experimental sample and the broader workforce.

Varying the effective wage while holding job characteristics constant isolates the substitution effect of working additional hours.

Willingness to take a longer job depends on the effective wage of the extra hours rather than the average wage level.

Anchoring hypothetical vignette wages directly to each respondent's real-world baseline earnings creates realistic choice scenarios.

Separating random choices from attentive choices prevents cognitive noise from flattening the estimated wage slope.

Statutory overtime rules require high effective wages, resulting in high baseline acceptance rates where most applicants choose the longer hours position.

Assuming a logistic distribution for individual time values, the probability of choosing the longer job equals the cumulative distribution function evaluated at the effective wage.

Job choices depend on effective marginal earnings rather than presentation style when applicants evaluate compensation accurately.

Forcing candidates to click on both position descriptions and manually type their preferred position number ensures that applicants thoroughly read both job offers before choosing.

Working full-time requires individuals to give up both leisure time and financial resources associated with staying home.