Source · aikyam school

Sectoral Employment Programs as a Path to Quality Jobs: Lessons from Randomized Evaluations

Original source

Samuel Lee; Caroline Garau

Sectoral Employment Programs as a Path to Quality Jobs: Lessons from Randomized Evaluations (2022)

secondary evidence review · J-PAL Evidence Review

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Embed mandatory non-technical workshops covering time management, critical thinking, professional communication, and conflict resolution into technical training schedules.

"Sectoral employment programs also include training in non-technical skills in the area of career readiness. These include instruction and training in abilities like time management, study skills, critical thinking, and conflict resolution."

Deploy sector-focused employment interventions to connect non-college workers to high-demand technical sectors that restore real wage growth.

"From 1979 to 2018, the top 0.1 percent has seen its earnings grow fifteen times faster than the bottom ninety percent, which has only seen consistent wage growth in ten of the past forty years."

Incorporate weekly cash stipends and emergency transit/childcare assistance funds into full-time technical training programs to prevent financial attrition.

"Programs may provide participants with financial support to make participation in these programs viable. This can take the form of weekly cash stipends or support in paying for necessities such as books, transportation, childcare, and food."

Establish formal employer advisory committees to audit skill demand and directly co-design technical training coursework prior to launching workforce cohorts.

"The focus on sectors with current and expected strong labor demand and close staff involvement with employers minimizes the risk of misalignment with the labor market that is thought to be an issue with some publicly funded training programs."

Establish structured post-placement outreach where career coaches contact placed employees and supervisors multiple times per week to navigate workplace challenges and provide emergency retention support.

"Through retention services that occur after the program has been completed, program staff continue to communicate and connect with previous participants. This outreach may better allow participants to overcome problems of supervisor implicit bias and discrimination against minority and non-traditional employees in the workplace."

Partner community college vocational degree tracks with comprehensive tuition support, mandatory weekly life-skills counseling, and direct health sector hiring channels.

"Its impacts on earnings in the eleven year study period were the longest-sustained increases ever found in a rigorous evaluation of a United States workforce development program."

Perform multi-year longitudinal benefit-cost evaluations on intensive workforce investments to evaluate fiscal returns and social net gains beyond immediate budget cycles.

"Results in this long-term follow-up also found that the program's benefits to society surpassed its costs. The net gain was $15,349 per participant... implying that the public received $1.66 for every $1 spent on the program."

Partner workforce initiatives with third-party industry advocates who verify candidate qualifications and provide employer-side post-hire retention counseling to overcome structural hiring barriers.

"From 2000 to 2019, the median wages of Black workers were 75.6 percent of white workers' median wages. These disparities often stem from structural barriers to opportunities faced by people of color in the American job market."

Mandate randomized lottery assignment among qualified workforce applicants during pilot program rollouts to establish rigorous causal evidence of earnings impact before national scaling.

"Randomly sorting a population into two groups--one that receives a program and one that does not--ensures that the groups are, on average, balanced at the beginning of the study."

Design sector-focused training initiatives in collaboration with local employers that lead directly to industry-recognized certifications in healthcare, IT, and manufacturing.

"Participants across all three programs earned a significant amount-$4,500 (an 18 percent increase) -more than those in the control group over the two year study period."

Structure sector training programs around widely accepted industry certifications to establish portable skill signals for non-traditional job seekers.

"The transferable nature of the skills attained as well as the official certifications earned through the occupational skills training provided by sectoral employment programs may be a key element of the long-term earnings gains demonstrated by these programs."

Incorporate mandatory pre-enrollment literacy and math assessments alongside motivational evaluations to select candidates most prepared for sector-specific technical training.

"Sectoral employment programs generally undertake some upfront screening for the motivations and basic skills (math and literacy) possessed by potential participants to focus program resources on candidates deemed most likely to benefit by program operators."

Establish a multi-site sectoral training initiative that mandates pre-enrollment skill screening, industry-aligned technical certifications, and dedicated post-placement retention coaching.

"The pooled results across the four providers show that as a whole, Work Advance increased earnings among participants by approximately $1,945 (about a 14 percent increase) in the second year studied and $2,716 (about an 11 percent increase) in the fifth year studied."

Implement a dual-phase youth workforce intervention pairing six months of full-time occupational instruction with six-month corporate internships backed by weekly stipends and social worker case management.

"By the third year in the study period, YearUp participants saw their earnings increase by $7,011 (a 40 percent increase) overall."

Career readiness capabilities equip trainees with essential non-technical skills required to navigate corporate environments.

Partnering with community colleges allows programs to leverage established academic institutions without building independent classrooms.

Internships allow participants to put both technical and non-technical skills into practice in real-world work environments.

Financial stipends make full-time program participation viable for low-income job seekers who would otherwise need immediate wage income.

Aligning technical skills training directly with sector standards ensures participants acquire portable credentials and verifiable capabilities.

Building relationships with sector employers creates trusted hiring channels that bypass traditional application screening barriers.

Targeting industries with strong labor demand ensures improvements in worker skills align directly with hiring needs.

Credentials provide a clear signal to employers that job seekers possess specific technical capabilities.

Post-hire outreach allows participants to overcome supervisor implicit bias and workplace discrimination against non-traditional employees.

Randomly sorting applicants into treatment and control groups ensures both groups are balanced on average at the start of the study.

Dedicated social worker support provides an emotional and practical buffer against personal life stresses.

Screening focuses program resources on candidates deemed most likely to benefit by program operators.