Source · aikyam school

Estimating the Effect of Unearned Income on Labor Earnings, Savings, and Consumption: Evidence from a Survey of Lottery Players

Original source

Guido W. Imbens; Donald B. Rubin; Bruce I. Sacerdote

Estimating the Effect of Unearned Income on Labor Earnings, Savings, and Consumption: Evidence from a Survey of Lottery Players (2001)

journal article

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

1. Incorporate signed administrative record consent releases in survey protocols to replace self-reported retrospective income questions with official government earnings panels.

"We asked respondents to authorize the release of their Social Security earnings records to us. For those who signed the Social Security release forms, we have accurate earnings records for at least six years preceding and six years following the time of winning."

1. Incorporate a 2.3-fold greater work reduction response among workers aged 55–65 compared to younger workers when modeling unearned income impact on retirement decisions.

"Individuals between 55 and 65 at the time of winning the lottery reduce their labor earnings significantly more than younger workers. Looking at the average post-lottery earnings, their MPE is lower by -0.167 (0.070)."

1. Apply identical labor supply reduction coefficients across male and female populations when modeling non-wage income transfers or universal basic income policies.

"More surprisingly, we find no significant differences between men and women in terms of the marginal propensity to earn out of unearned income. All estimates of the differences are extremely close to zero, with some negative and some positive estimates, and none is significant for the average of post-lottery years or for any of the post-lottery years separately."

1. Factor a 1-to-2-year transition period into economic forecasting models before expecting labor supply reductions to reach full steady-state levels following a cash transfer policy.

"However, even during the first full year after winning the lottery the estimated MPE is much lower than that in subsequent years, at -0.056 (0.25). After the first post-lottery year, the MPE stabilizes around -0.10 (0.03)."

1. Apply a 1.4% allocation coefficient for vehicles and 3.7% for real estate when estimating physical durable asset purchases resulting from multi-year unearned cash transfers.

"Some of the lottery winnings are spent on cars, with a marginal propensity to consume of 1.4 percent, and housing, with a marginal propensity to consume around 3.7 percent."

1. Calculate long-term capital accumulation from multi-year annuity payouts by multiplying total received disbursements by an empirical savings factor of 0.16.

"Adding up the two savings measures leads to similar results, with our preferred estimate of the marginal propensity to save out of unearned income based on the sample without nonwinners and big winners equal to 15.8 percent (5.6 percent)."

1. Implement quadratic functional specifications or trim extreme upper-tail outliers when modeling labor supply elasticities from skewed financial transfer distributions.

"Because the distribution of prizes is so skewed, with a minimum of zero, a median yearly prize equal to $32,000 and a maximum equal to $500,000, the few very large observations disproportionally affect the linear regression estimates."

1. Include small unconditional upfront cash payments in survey mailings rather than relying solely on larger conditional post-completion financial promises when sampling hard-to-reach populations.

"Consistent with Philipson's (1997) findings, the incentive scheme with $10 up front and a promise of $40 more rather than a promise of $50 did lead to a higher response rate (23 versus 16 percent)."

Official administrative records eliminate survey recall errors and deliberate reporting distortions.

Unearned income allows households to upgrade durable assets like cars and homes immediately.

Express courier delivery increases the likelihood that recipients pay attention to incoming survey mailings.

Excluding rare extreme outliers prevents high-leverage data points from pulling the linear regression line toward an artificial slope.

Summing across both retirement and liquid asset categories captures the full spectrum of household wealth accumulation.

First-differencing removes individual-specific time-invariant baseline differences that create noise across respondents.

Interaction terms isolate incremental behavioral changes attributable to specific demographic traits while controlling for overall baseline trends.

Imputing zeros for missing account categories prevents the unnecessary drop of valid partial responses.

Pre-testing survey protocols on a small sample reveals unexpected nonresponse patterns and operational flaws early.

Demographic post-stratification weighting balances differences in age, gender, and schooling structures across survey datasets.

Linear regressions force a constant slope across all payment levels, allowing rare multi-million dollar jackpots to distort estimated labor responses.

Stone-Geary utility functions allow essential baseline consumption and leisure thresholds to be held constant while isolating how unearned income expands discretionary wealth.

Paying participants prior to responding increases recipient attention and leverages psychological reciprocity.