Source · aikyam school

Who Debates, Who Wins? At-Scale Experimental Evidence on Debate Participation in a Liberian Election

Original source

Jeremy Bowles; Horacio Larreguy

Who Debates, Who Wins? At-Scale Experimental Evidence on Debate Participation in a Liberian Election (2019)

Working paper · CID Faculty Working Paper · No. 375 · Center for International Development at Harvard University

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Full source notice

© Copyright 2019 Bowles, Jeremy; Larreguy, Horacio; and the President and Fellows of Harvard College

Used in these cards

Pre-defining candidate competitiveness tiers using historical and party data avoids endogeneity from actual post-election vote shares.

Separating compliers from always-takers and never-takers isolates whether political candidates possess the sophistication to anticipate voter responses.

Cell phone surveys enable rapid, repeated data collection across dispersed geographical populations at lower cost than in-person interviews.

Open-ended questions capture genuine constituent demands without imposing restrictive choices.

Standardized text transcribing and coding converts qualitative speech into verifiable numeric metrics.

By emphasizing the credibility of the debates and clarifying their policy focus, the additional recruitment effort reduces candidate uncertainty about the risks and returns of attending.

Deploying external observers to listen to every scheduled broadcast creates direct oversight over radio station managers.

Using pre-determined baseline covariates to predict debate performance generates a fixed measure of candidate debate quality that is independent of actual debate attendance and treatment assignment.

Grounding debate moderation in researched district issues forces candidates to discuss specific local public goods rather than relying on vague generalities or personal attacks.

Radio ownership and daily listenership remain high even in remote areas with poor infrastructure.

Administrative electoral returns provide an objective, un-manipulated measurement of citizen voting choices across entire populations, eliminating recall and misreporting biases inherent in voter surveys.

Directly surveying candidates reveals strategic campaign responses and political sophistication that administrative election returns and voter surveys cannot capture.

Group discussions allow citizens to articulate in their own words how debate attendance, candidate platforms, and policy promises influenced their electoral deliberations.