Source · aikyam school

Do Management Interventions Last? Evidence from India

Original source

Nicholas Bloom; Aprajit Mahajan; David McKenzie; John Roberts

Do Management Interventions Last? Evidence from India

Dated research draft · Version date: 20 June 2018

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Prioritize implementing structural, low-maintenance routines (such as physical labeling and systematic maintenance schedules) over labor-intensive daily visual record updating.

"Of our 38 practices, once adopted, 14 are not dropped by a single plant, and a further 8 are dropped by at most one-quarter of adopters... Particularly noticeable among these sticky practices are that those which were adopted by 10 or more plants and then never dropped."

Focus management transformation programs on embedding standard industry-wide operational practices before introducing complex or novel analytical routines.

"...the positive coefficient indicates that common practices were more likely to be maintained (so uncommon practices were more likely to be dropped). This highlights that the intervention was more successful at getting badly managed plants to adopt relatively standard practices..."

Extend standardized operational monitoring systems and data-driven evaluation protocols from manufacturing plants into commercial sales, marketing, and external advisory engagements.

"Improving production and human-resource management practices led firms to value a more data-driven, systematic management approach, and hence apply this to other areas like marketing."

Delegate operational compliance tracking to dedicated plant-level supervisors so daily monitoring routines do not rely on the physical presence or time of senior executives.

"Another major factor across all the plants was director time – overall 3.6% of practices were dropped when directors had to reduce the time they spent managing the plant, often because of other business commitments..."

Establish formal industry benchmarking consortiums or structured peer-learning networks to facilitate cross-company observation and management practice transfer.

"...while few management practices had demonstrably spread across the firms in the study, many had spread within firms, from the experimental plants to the non-experimental plants, suggesting limited spillovers between firms but large spillovers within firms."

Calculate expected profit gains from quality defect reductions and machine downtime prevention before commissioning external operational consulting services.

"These improvements were estimated to have increased profits per plant by about $325,000 per year. We estimate that this represented, on average, a 130% one-year return on the market cost of the consulting services."

Instilling disciplined operational tracking leads firm directors to value systematic, data-driven decision-making across all business functions.

Recording defects by specific categories provides actionable operational data that allows managers to pinpoint exact machinery or handling errors.

Logging yarn storage by specific physical locations eliminates time wasted searching for misplaced raw materials on factory floors.

Revisiting facilities with identical scoring grids provides objective measures of long-term practice depreciation and retention.

Employees spend less shift time fixing machinery jams and repairing defective fabric when preventive maintenance and quality tracking are active.

Systematically tracking and monitoring downtime reasons transforms isolated machine stoppages into actionable operational data.

Directly linking attendance and output metrics to monetary bonuses aligns non-managerial staff incentives with plant production goals.

Systematically auditing existing factory routines reveals unmonitored inefficiencies and benchmarking gaps to firm leadership.

Planning production by specific customer orders aligns raw yarn inventory with active weaving schedules.

Formalizing handover protocols prevents incoming managers from discarding established shop-floor systems that they did not personally set up.

Routine loom maintenance and breakdown monitoring reduce unexpected equipment failures and keep factory spaces clean.

Bringing sales and operational managers together in structured review meetings breaks down departmental silos and prevents sales staff from making unachievable delivery promises.

Posting visual procedures creates clear baseline standards for daily tasks across factory shifts.

Establishing standardized quality tiers replaces subjective fabric inspections with objective defect thresholds.

Tracking inventory age prevents raw materials from rotting or losing quality on warehouse floors.

Organizing spare parts with clear labels and demarked locations eliminates time lost searching for misplaced machinery components.

Hands-on consultant assistance builds director confidence and demonstrates quick pay-offs in quality control and inventory management.