Source · aikyam school

How Does Risk Management Influence Production Decisions? Evidence from a Field Experiment

Original source

Shawn Cole; Xavier Giné; James Vickery

How Does Risk Management Influence Production Decisions? Evidence from a Field Experiment

Working paper · Harvard Business School working-paper copy · Working Paper 13-080 · Version date: 25 March 2013

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Full source notice

Copyright © 2013 by Shawn Cole, Xavier Giné, and James Vickery Working papers are in draft form. This working paper is distributed for purposes of comment and discussion only. It may not be reproduced without permission of the copyright holder. Copies of working papers are available from the author.

Used in these cards

Streamline microinsurance administration using digital verification and mobile settlement channels to lower loading factors below consumer willingness-to-pay thresholds.

Deploy dense networks of automated weather stations or satellite-derived rainfall indices to reduce distance-induced basis risk before marketing index insurance to smallholder producers.

Regulate private microinsurance contract structures to prevent insurers from exploiting consumer behavioral biases through high-frequency, low-value policy tweaks that under-protect against severe tail events.

Randomize and test presentation sequences when deploying incentive-compatible BDM auctions to ensure contract valuation measurements are free from cognitive anchoring biases.

Conduct practice bidding rounds using simple tangible items like chocolate bars before administering BDM willingness-to-pay mechanisms for complex financial products.

Regulate and standardize retail index insurance contract parameters to prevent commercial insurers from offering policies that exploit consumer misvaluation of severe tail events.

Introduce targeted risk-hedging financial instruments to reduce uninsurable background risk, enabling risk-averse producers to reallocate capital into higher-yielding production activities.

Integrate parametric rainfall index insurance into national climate adaptation strategies to protect agricultural productivity against rising monsoon volatility.

Issue parametric weather insurance prior to sowing windows to prevent panic-driven crop abandonment during early-season rainfall deficits.

Promote high-yield cash crops only when bundled with risk-hedging products, as high moisture thresholds create catastrophic downside losses during rainfall deficits.

Bundle weather index insurance with targeted access to chemical pesticides, as risk-hedged producers specifically expand crop-protection inputs to secure high-value cash crop yields.

Combine novel financial product rollouts with targeted financial literacy training and simplified product messaging to ensure equitable adoption among uneducated producers.

Evaluate microinsurance interventions by measuring early-season production choices and capital commitments rather than limiting impact evaluations to post-disaster payout distributions.

Distribute insurance contracts prior to initial planting windows so producers can adjust input decisions under active risk hedging rather than post-disaster expectations.

Account for participant study fatigue and novelty bias when measuring willingness to pay for novel financial services across multi-year experimental panels.

Target agricultural risk-reduction subsidies at non-commercial farmers who are near the threshold of entering commercial cash crop production to maximize extensive-margin adoption.

Target agricultural risk-management subsidies at smallholders operating just below cash-crop entry thresholds to overcome fixed-cost scale barriers to commercial crop adoption.

Assess consumer financial sophistication before introducing complex parametric insurance products, pairing sales with decision-support tools for low-sophistication clients.

Assess consumer financial sophistication prior to launching microinsurance products to ensure target populations accurately comprehend and value key risk-hedging clauses.

Deploy state-contingent hedging instruments to decouple investment decisions from background volatility in credit- and risk-constrained enterprises.

Bundle high-yielding seed varieties and fertilizer subsidies directly with index weather insurance to accelerate technology adoption among risk-averse smallholders.

Pair microinsurance rollouts with targeted financial literacy training or simplified visual contract terms to ensure low-literacy farmers comprehend and utilize risk-hedging mechanisms.

Construct dense networks of automated weather stations or integrate remote-sensing satellite data to minimize reference station distance and reduce basis risk in agricultural microinsurance.

Replace individual crop indemnity contracts with exogenous parametric weather index insurance to eliminate administrative verification costs and moral hazard risks.

Distribute parametric index insurance through existing community savings groups or self-help groups (SHGs) to align formal drought protection with informal social safety nets.

Automate weather station data transmission and streamline institutional payout approval workflows to ensure claims are settled before the subsequent planting cycle.

Structure international reinsurance contracts for local weather indices to leverage global market decorrelation and reduce capital holding costs for emerging market agricultural insurers.

Supply targeted voucher discounts or credit lines for crop-protection inputs alongside weather insurance to support cash crop adoption.

Design parametric weather index contracts with distinct phase-based triggers aligned with critical crop phenology stages rather than season-wide rainfall totals.

Offer retail rainfall index insurance linked to local rain gauges to smallholders prior to monsoon onset to enable investment in higher-yielding, higher-risk crops.

Utilize mobile payment infrastructure and automated weather data pipelines to compress administrative loading factors, enabling retail index insurance pricing below median smallholder willingness to pay.

Evaluate agricultural risk interventions based on intra-portfolio input reallocation rather than expecting immediate expansion of total land under cultivation.

Establish targeted rainfall index insurance to buffer weather shocks, enabling farmers to transition away from loss-making subsistence crops to high-return cash crops.

Design retail agricultural index insurance programs without wealth-targeted stratification, as smallholder production responses to risk reduction operate independently of baseline asset levels.

The BDM mechanism is incentive-compatible because a participant cannot influence the purchase price if they win, as the price is determined randomly after placing the bid.

Randomizing contract features within an incentive-compatible bidding structure isolates how specific terms influence willingness-to-pay.

Equalizing the expected monetary value and payout timing between treatment and control groups holds household expected wealth constant.

Index insurance eliminates moral hazard and claims verification delays because payouts depend entirely on objective third-party weather measurements.

Using physical scratch cards ensures double-blind conditions during pre-treatment survey administration.

Targeted input subsidies lower the marginal cost of chemical fertilizers, enabling credit-constrained farmers to increase nutrient application rates on high-value crops.

Collecting post-harvest data directly from producers captures the cumulative impact of seasonal risk management treatments on real capital allocation.

Simulating the BDM mechanism with a tangible, low-stakes item gives subjects hands-on experience with the pricing rules and payoff structure.

Providing clear agronomic guidelines directly to farmers lowers information barriers regarding optimal crop nutrition.