Original source
Does Management Matter? Evidence from India
Journal article · The Quarterly Journal of Economics · 128(1), 1–51 · Version date: February 2013
Read the source ↗© The Author(s) 2012. All rights reserved.
Permission for School’s use is unestablished.
Full source notice
! The Author(s) 2012. Published by Oxford University Press, on behalf of President and Fellows of Harvard College. All rights reserved. For Permissions, please email: journals .permissions@oup.com
Used in these cards
Structure financial assistance or subsidy programs specifically for intangible operational training and advisory services rather than physical equipment acquisitions when targeting enterprise productivity.
"So investments on the scale of $3,000 (the first-year costs of these management changes excluding the consultants' fees) are unlikely to be directly impeded by financial constraints. Of course, financial constraints could impede hiring international consultants. The estimated market cost of our free consulting would be $250,000, and, as an intangible investment, it would be difficult to collateralize."
Implement mandatory visual displays and structured daily tracking logs to force managerial attention onto non-obvious operational metrics.
"Recent work by Schwartzstein (2012) and Hanna, Mullainathan, and Schwartzstein (2012) highlights, however, that cognitive limitations could prevent directors and managers from noting the impact of such variables that they had not thought important, so the information would be ignored."
Utilize verified third-party research partnerships or government-backed demonstration projects to overcome trust and informational barriers when sourcing external management advice.
"Indian firms are bombarded with solicitations from businesses offering to save them money on everything from telephone bills to yarn supplies, and thus are unlikely to be receptive."
Systematically benchmark firm management scores against international industry standards using standardized double-blind evaluation frameworks to identify tail underperformance.
"The results reveal a thick tail of badly run Indian firms, leading to a lower average management score (2.69 for India versus 3.33 for U.S. firms)."
Track material waste, weaver labor hours, and defect rates at the specific product-design level to base pricing and catalog offerings on actual design cost rather than plant-wide averages.
"Using design-wise efficiency analysis so pricing can be based on actual (rather than average) production costs."
Utilize double-blind, scenario-based open question scoring frameworks to evaluate organizational management practices without triggering self-reporting bias.
"The BVR methodology scores firms from 1 (worst practice) to 5 (best practice) on management practices related to monitoring, targets, and incentives. Aggregating these scores yields a basic measure of the use of modern management practices that is strongly correlated with a wide range of firm performance measures..."
Compare volunteer program participants against non-participating industry populations across observable baseline metrics to test for self-selection bias and verify external validity.
"We found the 17 project firms were not significantly different in terms of preintervention observables from the 96 nonproject firms that responded to this survey."
Policy makers should reduce trade protection tariffs and remove credit market barriers to strengthen market competition against inefficient incumbent producers.
"Because spans of control are constrained, productive firms are limited from expanding, so reallocation does not drive out badly run firms. Because entry is limited, new firms do not enter rapidly."
Incorporate diagnostic-only control groups receiving identical observation intensity when testing management or process interventions to isolate genuine operational effects from Hawthorne worker behavior shifts.
"Both sets of plants got the initial diagnostic period and the follow-up measurement period, with the only difference being the treatment plants also got an intensive consulting during the intermediate implementation stage... Hence, it cannot be simply the presence of the consultants or the measurement of performance that generated the relative improvement in performance of treatment firms."
1. Conduct an operational audit of factory processes by implementing daily tracking logs for quality defects and machine downtime to identify unmeasured operational losses.
Establish daily recording and review meetings for quality defects, machine downtime, and inventory stock levels to convert operational bottlenecks into visible, actionable data.
"Our results suggest that informational barriers were the primary factor explaining this lack of adoption."
1. Replicate newly validated standard operating procedures from pilot production units across all secondary operational plants owned by the same corporate parent before attempting external licensing or benchmark disclosures.
"As a result, although spillovers across plants within firms occurred rapidly as shown in Figure V, spillovers between firms were very limited."
Catalog, label, and electronically record all warehouse inventory while establishing explicit minimum reordering thresholds and aging logs to purge dead stock.
"After cataloging, the firms sold or used up the surplus yarn (by incorporation into new designs), and then introduced restocking norms for future purchases and monitored against these weekly."
Sort, label, and establish computer-logged location tracking for raw material inventory while establishing strict reordering norms to eliminate dead stock.
"We find that adopting these management practices raised productivity by 17% in the first year through improved quality and efficiency and reduced inventory, and within three years led to the opening of more production plants."
Instrument self-reported or observed management practice indices with exogenous random assignment variables when evaluating productivity impacts to avoid downward attenuation bias.
"We find that the fixed-effects estimates tend to understate the gain in performance from better management, which is consistent with changes in management being more likely to be implemented when outcomes are declining."
1. Allocate capital expenditure budgets to include standard operating procedure (SOP) design and operational tracking software alongside physical hardware purchases to ensure full asset productivity.
"So given the $250,000 that the consultancy reported it would have charged an individual firm for comparable services if it paid directly, this implies about a 130% one-year rate of return."
Pair all data tracking systems with daily review meetings and formal action plans to ensure collected operational metrics drive corrective interventions.
"Implementing these practices to monitor and electronically record data without implementing the complementary practices to use and act on these data is intuitively likely to have more limited effects."
Embed newly introduced operational standard operating procedures into daily supervisor routines and visual tracking templates to ensure long-term persistence without continuous external oversight.
"These improvements in management practices were also persistent. The management practice adoption rates dropped by only 3 percentage points, on average, between the end of the first wave in August 2010 (when the consultants left) and the start of the second wave in August 2011."
1. Eliminate regulatory plant-size thresholds and import tariffs to allow competitive market selection to reallocate output toward high-productivity plants.
"Because spans of control are constrained, productive firms are limited from expanding, so reallocation does not drive out badly run firms."
Establish performance-based incentive bonuses and explicit operational authority thresholds for middle managers to align non-family staff interests with enterprise performance.
"They had both limited control over factory management and also limited incentives to improve performance because promotion is not possible (only family members can become directors) and there were no bonus systems..."
Schedule dedicated, recurring execution blocks and assign external implementation facilitators to prevent operational improvements from being derailed by executive routine demands.
"Although initially owners' time accounted for only 3.7% of nonadoption in treatment plants, by nine months it accounted for 14.0% as a backlog of management changes built up that the owners struggled to implement."
Establish transparent, metric-based monthly bonus programs for worker attendance and production efficiency paired with prominent factory floor performance scoreboards.
"Visual displays around the factory floor together with the incentive schemes also encouraged workers to improve operating efficiency and attendance levels."
Create a daily machine breakdown log categorized by fault type and implement manufacturer-recommended scheduled preventive maintenance routines across all critical plant equipment.
"Regular maintenance of machines and recording the reasons for breakdowns to learn from failures."
Structure enterprise expansion plans around building separate modular production facilities when operating in jurisdictions where labor laws and unionization rules apply on a per-facility basis.
"Expansion occurred through increasing the number of plants (as opposed to expanding current plants) as this apparently reduced the risk of unionization and regulatory problems."
Establish judicial enforcement mechanisms and contract recovery institutions to reduce agency risk and facilitate managerial delegation.
"Even if directors found managers stealing, their ability to successfully prosecute them and recover the assets is likely minimal because of the inefficiency of Indian courts."
Collect high-frequency repeated measurements over extended time horizons when running interventions on small sample populations to achieve sufficient statistical power and exact inference.
"To address concerns over statistical inference in small samples, we implemented permutation tests whose properties are independent of sample size. We also exploited our large time series of around 100 weeks of data per plant by using estimators that rely on large T (rather than large N) asymptotics."
Establish robust operational monitoring and preventive maintenance protocols prior to investing in advanced manufacturing equipment to protect capital expenditure returns.
"The firm directors began replacing older Sulzer and Rapier looms with Jacquard looms, which produce higher mark-up fabric but require more advanced quality control and maintenance practices."