Source · aikyam school

Employment Exposure: Employment and Wage Effects in Urban Malawi

Original source

Susan Godlonton

Employment Exposure: Employment and Wage Effects in Urban Malawi (2020)

Journal article · Economic Development and Cultural Change · 68(2), 471–506

Read the source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Full source notice

© 2019 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

Used in these cards

Target active labor market experience interventions toward job applicants with lower formal test scores to overcome initial employer screening barriers.

"Individuals at the 25th percentile were 25 percentage points more likely to be employed if they were induced to receive job experience through the experiment; they also earn approximately $11.01 more per day."

Collect granular panel or calendar history data on actual days worked rather than using age-schooling formulas when evaluating returns to labor in developing countries.

"Potential experience is considered a poor proxy in general, and the prevalence of interrupted or delayed schooling and periods of unemployment in the developing-country context renders this an even poorer proxy for actual experience in these areas."

Plot cumulative distribution functions of wage outcomes when evaluating employment interventions to confirm that wage growth is broad-based across all income quantiles.

Plot and evaluate cumulative distribution functions of post-program earnings to confirm that average intervention effects represent broad-based wage increases.

"These wage impacts do not appear to be concentrated among a few individuals; rather, we see a distributional shift among those acquiring the short-term work experience opportunity."

Reallocate public policy funding in low-income labor markets from standalone classroom skills training toward direct capital injections and micro-grants for job seekers.

"They find little support that skills training has been effective and instead push for policy makers to place more emphasis on programs that include capital injections, as the evidence base increasingly suggests that such policies are more effective"

Implement targeted 5-day paid work placement programs for young secondary school graduates in low-income urban areas to accelerate wage growth and private-sector employment integration.

"The work experience opportunity provided in the experiment increases average wages by slightly less than $4 per day during the postintervention period."

Evaluate youth employment interventions using both daily wage metrics and contract duration indicators to measure long-term job stability alongside wage growth.

"The negative coefficient suggests that individuals induced to receive work experience through the experiment work in less permanent positions."

Combine formal secondary education completion initiatives with practical workplace transition programs to resolve structural underemployment among educated urban youth.

"Data from a nationally representative household survey shows that urban men who have completed secondary school work only 23.4 hours per week, conditional on being employed."

Disentangle firm-specific training content from general skills when evaluating whether active labor market program returns reflect human capital or alternative mechanisms like social networking.

"Skills related to this particular questionnaire are highly firm- and project-specific and are unlikely to be valuable in the general labor market."

Provide active resume-updating assistance to job seekers in developing labor markets to ensure all informal and short-term work experiences are documented for prospective employers.

"Roughly 15% of the sample had no previous work experience based on the self-reported measure of the baseline survey. This number rises to 35% when measured using work experience reported on the participants' résumés."

Combine reference letter distribution programs with active workplace networking opportunities to maximize candidate signaling and job placement channels.

Prioritize direct workplace referral integrations over post-program reference letter issuance when designing active labor market interventions.

"Column 5 of table 9 shows that those who received work experience as a result of the experimental treatment were actually 7.9 percentage points less likely to use a reference letter when applying to a job."

Design active labor market policies and wage evaluations around days worked per week rather than hourly compensation rates in underemployed urban contexts.

"In this labor market, individuals are more likely to adjust their labor supply at the daily rather than the hourly margin; they are also paid per day rather than per hour."

Design youth employment placement programs in partnership with international employers or high-prestige organizations to maximize post-program wage premiums for participants.

Pair short-term work placement opportunities with active networking coaching for workers lacking prior international or short-term contract exposure.

Target advanced workplace experience interventions toward individuals with existing specialized research backgrounds to compound technical wage premiums.

"Yet, the wage returns are magnified for those with either international employer or existing research experience."

Categorize retrospective employment history data using standard ISCO occupational codes to track structural transitions out of primary agriculture into administrative sectors.

"However, the pattern of results suggests that work experience increases employment in both administrative and managerial roles, as well as in clerical and related work, whereas it reduces employment in agriculture and related occupations."

Implement guaranteed baseline employment safety nets during competitive hiring filters to eliminate anxiety-driven underperformance among candidates.

Incorporate probabilistic fallback job guarantees or safety cushions into high-stakes recruitment and assessment settings to reduce evaluation stress and improve applicant test performance.

"Godlonton (2020) shows that a possible pathway for this behavior is a stress response: individuals with more secure outside options were able to perform better due to reduced stress related to job uncertainty."

Prioritize low-scoring or lower-ability job applicants for short-term workplace exposure opportunities to maximize economic returns and overcome hiring screening barriers.

"Individuals of lower ability (as assessed by a numeracy and literacy test) benefit the most from the work experience."

Encourage job seekers participating in short-term specialized employment opportunities to apply for non-specialized private sector roles to capture cross-sectoral wage premiums.

"Although the point estimates are positive for both RA positions and non-RA positions, the large wage returns seem to be driven by employment in non-RA positions."

Disaggregate employment intervention outcomes into program-adjacent versus external non-program sectors to verify true cross-industry labor market mobility.

"The employment results mirror the earlier findings: we estimate (noisy) positive point estimates of the impact of the experience on employment in RA positions... and non-RA positions. We observe a very interesting pattern for wages... the large wage returns seem to be driven by employment in non-RA positions."

Calculate conservative Manski bounds and inverse probability weights on follow-up data to verify that differential survey attrition does not drive experimental findings.

"To address concerns related to the nontrivial level of attrition, we conduct two bounding exercises... In both cases, we find broadly consistent results."

Utilize worker remuneration frequency metrics as a proxy for job contract permanence when formal employment contracts are unobserved.

"We infer that lower-frequency reporting levels correspond to longer duration contracts and construct a frequency of payment variable equal to 1 if the individual reports daily remuneration, 2 if weekly, 3 if fortnightly, and 4 if monthly remuneration."

Collect direct, event-history measurements of actual days worked rather than using potential experience formulas when evaluating human capital returns in developing economies.

"Potential experience is considered a poor proxy in general, and the prevalence of interrupted or delayed schooling and periods of unemployment in the developing-country context renders this an even poorer proxy for actual experience in these areas"

Structure pilot active labor market evaluations with probabilistic selection lotteries to construct valid instrumental variables for wage effect identification.

"The probabilistic outside options strongly predict the probability with which participants received any job (earned or lottery job)."

Introduce performance-contingent referral bonuses in private-sector recruitment to incentivize employees to recommend high-ability job applicants.

"In addition, when offered performance incentives for referral, men recommend higher-quality candidates, suggesting that under normal operating considerations, they do not necessarily recommend the highest-quality candidates they know."

Test reservation wage dynamics alongside job search intensity to rule out worker supply-side expectation shifts as the primary cause of wage growth.

Measure actual job search duration alongside reservation wage surveys to verify whether wage expectations create search frictions following temporary employment interventions.

"These results suggest that an increase in reservation wages is not likely an important pathway."

Collect both formal résumé documents and retrospective survey histories to distinguish between employer-visible signals and actual worker history.

"Roughly 15% of the sample had no previous work experience based on the self-reported measure... This number rises to 35% when measured using work experience reported on the participants' résumés."

Structure active labor market programs to incorporate collaborative tasks and supervisor interactions that foster informal job referral connections among participants.

"In sum, the broadened social (job) network acquired through this process seems to be a contributing factor in the large realized wage returns."

Design active labor market programs to maximize direct social interaction among participants and supervisors rather than relying exclusively on isolated technical instruction.

"Individuals who received work experience as a result of the experiment are 22.2 percentage points more likely to have heard about a work opportunity through someone they met during the intervention."

Standard reference letters certify that a worker completed short-term employment without revealing specific performance metrics.

Written assessment tests evaluate baseline cognitive skills that predict candidate performance on workplace tasks.

Randomizing job offer probabilities breaks the connection between unobserved worker traits and job placement.

Short-term work placement provides real workplace experience that expands participants' professional networks and connects them to informal job referrals.

Tracking specific contact pathways reveals how workplace interactions expand informal job search networks.

Excluding the immediate post-intervention month removes respondent confusion between experimental work assignments and independent labor market activity.