Source · aikyam school

Promoting Labour Market Inclusion: Evidence from the Inclusion Policy Lab in Spain and Across Europe

Original source

Inés Torres Rojas; Ana García-Hernández; Cillian Nolan

Promoting Labour Market Inclusion: Evidence from the Inclusion Policy Lab in Spain and Across Europe (2025)

J-PAL Europe evidence/policy report · J-PAL Europe

Search for this source ↗

Permission for School’s use is unestablished.

Used in these cards

Offer minimum income recipients bi-weekly 2.5-hour hands-on digital skills workshops paired with equal duration individual coaching focused on completing online administrative procedures and job applications.

"The program enhanced digital skills, particularly by improving participants' ability to use digital devices and the internet and complete online administrative procedures. Effects on capacity to secure employment, self-esteem, and satisfaction were positive but small in size."

Establish biweekly joint case-review meetings between municipal social caseworkers and public employment counselors to co-manage unified inclusion itineraries for minimum income recipients.

"The intervention increased participants' engagement in training programs and employment counselling and may have had a small and positive impact on the number of days worked and employment intensity. ... The program enhanced participants' empowerment, defined in this evaluation as a stable sense of personal competence to effectively manage a wide range of stressful situations..."

Assign specialized municipal caseworkers to conduct holistic intake assessments for minimum income recipients to streamline access and increase take-up of auxiliary social support programs.

"Results showed that this approach increased the take-up of social support programs offered by public social services but it did not increase the take-up of employment and training programs. ... The program did not impact life satisfaction or self-reported health, but it enhanced participants' mental health."

Deploy specialized social caseworkers to offer low-income mothers tailored one-stop support packages combining digital skills instruction, corporate job matching, and personal autonomy counseling.

"Compared to standard services, participants showed increased job search skills and professional competencies. ... The intervention enhanced personal autonomy and life satisfaction. The evaluation also identified positive impacts on mental health, housing conditions, and social interactions."

Structure adult vocational re-skilling programs so that certified classroom instruction (200+ hours) is mandatorily paired with a multi-month paid corporate internship and continuous job placement support.

"Compared to standard public employment services, the program enhanced participants' professional competencies, self-efficacy, proactivity, and motivation in the job search."

Provide low-income job seekers with internet-connected smartphones pre-loaded with employment apps and pair them with 39 hours of structured digital literacy instruction to improve online e-government task execution.

"Only the treatment that included digital skills training had a positive impact on the completion of online administrative procedures. None of the interventions impacted job search skills or intensity, access to and use of digital devices, self-perceived ability to secure employment, or life satisfaction."

Establish open-access physical hub spaces equipped with internet-connected computers and moderated peer messaging groups in local welfare offices to foster mutual assistance and active job search techniques.

"Relative to the comparison group, the program increased participants' job applications, participation in recruitment interviews and take-up of professional or vocational training. It also had a large, positive impact on households' income."

Integrate municipal social assistance and public employment services into unified single-window intake centers that conduct holistic family needs assessments and assign dedicated caseworkers to coordinate multi-sectoral support plans.

"Compared to families that received the standard social support, the one-stop window improved the overall indicator of social inclusion, with improvements in the measures of housing conditions, parental skills and family satisfaction, community integration, and education performance."

Combine direct employer matching liaisons with eight mandatory digital skills training sessions to boost full-time employment rates among job seekers at risk of poverty.

"Treatment 2 added eight additional digital skills sessions to Treatment 1. ... Treatment 2 improved employment conditions, including the probability of full-time employment, the number of full-time days worked, and employment intensity."

Deploy specialized job developers to perform individual discovery assessments and negotiate customized, task-tailored job contracts directly with local business owners for job seekers with intellectual disabilities.

"The CEM led to increases of 2.3 hours worked per week (73 percent more than the comparison group), and 0.14 work contracts (45 percent) in the last year, although there was no higher employment rate at the endline."

Pair hardware equipment grants with mandatory, intensive hands-on digital literacy instruction to enable low-educated older welfare recipients to conduct online job searches and navigate digital administrative procedures.

"The Redlab program had a positive and substantial impact on digital skills, job search intensity, respondents' perceived ease of finding employment, and life satisfaction, with these effects persisting in the six months after the intervention ended."

Offer vulnerable mothers receiving welfare benefits integrated access to physical and psychological healthcare consultations alongside personalized job matching and entrepreneurship counseling.

"The health intervention improved participants' capacity to secure employment. The employment and combined treatments had a positive impact on earned income, although the evaluation did not identify any effect on the number of days or hours worked."

Embed structured hands-on business creation modules and industry networking events directly into vocational high school curricula to reduce student dropout rates.

"The program did not impact students' intention to start a business, but produced modest increases in participants' entrepreneurial attitudes and business behaviour. ... The intervention also led to a significant reduction in the dropout rate in further vocational education."

Assign three distinct mentors (educational, technical, and professional) to young, low-educated apprentices inside host companies to build foundational workplace competencies.

"Participants were assigned to a job vacancy, where they received support from three types of mentors: an educational mentor, a technical mentor within the company, and a professional mentor also within the company. ... It enhanced participants' core and transversal skills but did not lead to improved employment outcomes."

Lower caseworker caseloads to a 1:20 ratio for specialized caseworkers assisting unhoused job seekers to provide simultaneous flexible job search assistance, housing mediation, and post-employment retention support.

"According to administrative records, participants who received personalised support worked approximately fourteen days more during the six months following the intervention (an increase of roughly 80 percent relative to the comparison group)."

Integrate mandatory group psychosocial counseling and frustration-tolerance workshops directly into long-duration certified vocational training courses for long-term welfare recipients.

"The intervention improved several dimensions of personal autonomy, including reducing participants' risk of experiencing mental health problems, increasing their tolerance to frustration, enhancing their ability to identify problems, and improving their knowledge of public resources and digital skills."

Deliver 15-hour personal empowerment workshops prior to or alongside 50-80 hours of targeted vocational training to improve job search proactivity and psychological resilience among individuals at risk of poverty.

"The vocational training improved resilience, an overall indicator of job search behaviours and attitudes, as well as proactivity, organisation, and behaviour in job searching. The workshops enhanced overall job search behaviours and attitudes, motivation, and proactivity in the job search."

Integrate adult job placement and benefit navigation services with child academic tutoring and early childhood education within a single family-focused program.

"The combined treatment resulted in a reduction of material and social deprivation, an increase in monthly household income, an improvement in parents' expectations for their children's academic performance, and an improvement in standardised test scores for language and mathematics."

Providing shared physical and digital spaces breaks social isolation and encourages mutual motivation among participants.

Combining group instruction with individual tutoring allows participants to learn digital concepts collaboratively while resolving personal technical barriers with one-on-one assistance.

Pairing physical hardware with extensive hands-on instruction ensures participants gain practical confidence using digital tools.

Integrating digital literacy with direct corporate intermediation expands job search scope while securing direct access to hiring firms.

Addressing healthcare needs alongside job search barriers restores physical and psychological capacity to work.

Assigning dedicated municipal caseworkers lowers the administrative burden of navigating fragmented public assistance programs.

Customizing job descriptions to individual strengths removes standard recruitment hurdles for people with intellectual disabilities.

Combining formal classroom instruction with an extended paid internship restores technical competencies while preventing skill decay.

Providing free hardware and internet access removes financial and physical barriers to digital technology for low-income adults.

Combining peer group learning with individual career guidance builds practical job search competencies while helping participants overcome personal scheduling and family care barriers.

Addressing multiple family needs simultaneously removes underlying household stress and logistical barriers to social inclusion.

Combining psychosocial therapy with vocational retraining strengthens personal autonomy, frustration tolerance, and mental health.

Addressing child learning needs alongside parent employment barriers removes household stress and raises academic expectations.

Providing certified training in growth sectors restores technical competencies and equips job seekers with skills local employers need.

Combining company placement with structured triple mentoring provides direct workplace exposure and continuous personal guidance.

Combining personal goal setting with a dedicated mobile application gives job seekers an accessible repository for essential job documents.

Combining personalized social support with digital skills training and direct firm matching strengthens personal autonomy and mental well-being.

Building personal self-esteem addresses underlying psychological barriers to active job seeking.

Increasing caseworker-to-beneficiary ratios allows staff to provide tailored guidance that addresses each person's unique housing and health challenges.

Combining hardware access with guided instruction builds confidence and overcomes technical fear among digital beginners.

Youth tend to be less risk-averse and possess high capacity for innovation through social interactions.